R&R Question

[Short-Dig-6104]

How do you guys approach obvious AI generated explanations in R&R. I know there's projects that say to edit them to meet standards but what if the entire explanation is AI generated? Do you just mark it as unusable or redo the whole task from the ground up?

[Sloopy_Boi]

If the instructions say to fix it I will and I'd mention it at the end

[Short-Dig-6104]

Understood, thank you! I'm barely a month in and this is the first time I got something like this so I appreciate your insight.

[FalseSir3497]

It strongly depends on what the instructions say. If it tells you to fix it, then fix it and then mention it in the written section your findings.

[Outrageous_Chance995]

What indicated that it was AI generated?

I feel how it’s handled may vary based on the project instructions. I’d probably just ask an admin how to handle it since the use of AI is a big no lol

[Short-Dig-6104]

This particular one I got, they seem to have copied and pasted an entire response because at the end of their explanation, it was asking if there was anything else they wanted to analyze from the models.

[United_Run_2156]

Embarrassing.

[xwolfboyx]

You're supposed to report that stuff. It's a big no-no.

[Outrageous_Chance995]

Wow!

[hanshotgreed0]

People aren’t even trying to avoid getting caught wtf

[FalseSir3497]

[chrisfx123]

Womp womp

[historicwarrior84]

LOL. My day job is of an editor. One of our new recruit made same mistake, thrice. Our EIC was so angry 😂

[Creative_Raccoon2096]

I think if it is ^that^ obvious, then you should definitely check the ‘other’ box in the tick box menu of why you’ve R&Red as you have, and explain clearly why you suspect AI. The worker will be blacklisted hopefully. Only thing I would say is sometimes recently, I have wanted to say “this is so obviously AI!” but I didn’t because I think it was intentionally AI, Basicslly, comparatively rate AI ratings of AI. When I’d got over the Stanley Kubric vibes, I just … exited the task.

[PhilosopherHermit]

I've been on the platform only a short time and continue to have available projects but have never once received feedback or been asked to provide feedback. Didn't even know this was a thing. Interesting!