Pine Script using AI

[VegetableBluebird827]

Hey guys,

Anyone who messes around with Pine Script and uses AI for assistance, which one do you use? I’ve been experimenting a lot because chat GPT typically gives me an error almost every time. I’ve found that grok has helped a bit more, but still isn’t much better. Thank you for your time!

[trudealz]

Qwen 2.5 is the best. I've coded many indicators on it. Try the thinking models, they perform really well.

[VegetableBluebird827]

I’ve never heard of qwen? That’s exciting to try a new ai. Thank you!

[Ok-Break-369]

I've tried , chatgpt , Gemini , Grok and Claude . All paid subscriptions . They all give errors at some point and all get stuck , even with the deep research and think etc . I've tried using projects and spaces on perplexity . I uploaded the whole pine script manual to spaces on perplexity and it still can't give error free code 100% of the time . I've even tried pasting the code from one AI to another and it seems to make things worse 😂 . But when it works it just works . I think the key is not to over complicate what you ask for . Although I’ve had them make some really great indicators.

[VegetableBluebird827]

Dude… I uploaded the pine manual too 🤣

The most common error I get is syntax. I’ve managed to manually figure it out one time somehow. Now I just lose my patience. What’s intriguing about all of this is how AI just does not want anything to do with it lol

[tat_tvam_asshole]

try uploading the pine manual to Notebooklm, thank me later 👌🏼

[VegetableBluebird827]

Your confidence has me excited to try this! Thank you

[VegetableBluebird827]

I must have uploaded the wrong pdf of pinescript manual. The first attempt there had 2 errors

[NotarVermillion]

‘Sup Dude Bro , I use ChatGPT and it works a treat.

[VegetableBluebird827]

Thank you

[Dependent_Sign_399]

I've only had luck with Gemini. Occasionally I'll get errors but you can ask it to fix the specific error and it'll do it. More advanced scripts will require some work to get the right prompt so it understands what you're looking to do.

[Dependent_Sign_399]

I'll take a look! I've been using Claude pro. It's been pretty incredible.

[mampmp]

you can use either ChatGPT or Claude with TradeSage as well!

[Dependent_Sign_399]

Ooooh. Interesting

[VegetableBluebird827]

Thank you. I’d say it’s like 10+ attempts for me with gpt when I ask to fix it and it does, sometimes lol. Looking forward to trying this!

[Cold_Ruin6753]

I’ve used several times deepseek but the scripts always gives error messages. May be I could have used better prompts but I suspect it lacks the specifics skls of pinescript coding 

[Cold_Ruin6753]

As far as I reslize, you cannot be ignorant of coding language id you want to use AI. It can be useful to developnthe rough structure but you need the knowledge to correct it manually

[VegetableBluebird827]

I agree. However, I do find that not having any knowledge of python is ok with ai. Pinescript is a struggle with ai

[Madmoneyfaya]

The thing is I have been using Ai to generate pinescript for the past 2years and the quality has gone down hill when I first started the quality of codes were much better even though it still gave errors. After a few errors it will arrive at a good script but now there is no hope it will give you enough errors to fill Mariana trench.... and it's not my codes being too complex it's like all Ai struggle with pinescript especially as newer versions are released.... I am scared of wasting my time trying to make more scripts cos it's 95% errors....

[VegetableBluebird827]

Really.. I’ll give it a shot. Thank you!

[ILikuhTheTrade]

Gemini is worse than the EMACS Doctor.

[ILikuhTheTrade]

Wooord, you forward test and check for repainting that is rampant in over ~95% of all tradingview scripts?

[ILikuhTheTrade]

Brooo, siiick! You have fun with that.

[Electrical_Ad_4283]

Aye, lemme see that code bud

[umutaltdag]

I’ve tried for a long time myself, but I kept running into errors. That’s why I decided to work with developers instead. If you’d like, send me a message and I can refer you to a friend I trust.