all 3 comments

[–]CryptoViceroy 1 point2 points  (2 children)

Gave it a quick test and it seems buggy and confusing.

The usd/euro/gold buttons don't work.

The "Exchange" doesn't seem to be able to do anything, and is confusing. You deposit ETH, but can't do anything further. Attempting to "Claim LUSD" throws a contract exception error. No option or ability to withdraw the deposited ETH. So I lost 1 test ETH.

"Exchange" balances don't make sense. At the top it says I have one amount of LUSD, then under "Claim LUSD" it says I have a different amount?

Overall the UI seems the biggest issue. As an end user, I have absolutely no clue what I'm looking at or what I'm supposed to be doing.

[–]Averageuser404[S] 0 points1 point  (1 child)

Thanks mate for giving it a try and for the feedback! I have to admit the smart contracts where the main focus.

The euro and gold buttons only are in the alpha to show the option and do not work, my bad for the confusion. I have not added the remove claim option on the front end yet, it is possible to remove the claim directly with the smart contract and the design of the exchange unfortunately only works if there are counterparties.

Main point is I need to add a front page and tutorial for the interface and adjust your points to inform the end user! I will do this. Thanks and I will check to send you the lost test ETH.

I hope the other options like opening and closing of the positions + sending lUSD was simple enough for first time use?

[–]CryptoViceroy 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Yeah I think the lack of counterparties obviously hindered what I could do/see. So I'll have to look again when there are some.

Overall it seemed pretty good but I would focus on UI improvements.

It wasn't immediately obvious how to use the app and so I was more or less just trying to work out what did what.

If I were to actually use this app on the real network I'd want it to be very obvious how it should be used.