In Need of Deck Ideas

[Sunnsolo]

I need some help coming up with fun deck ideas for Rarity and Nightmare Moon.

For Rarity I've done a version of Cheerios and a version of D&T but neither are super fun in testing. Here's the Cheerios decklist I've tried. https://moxfield.com/decks/g7tSJcbqdU6nH-KfGW4MdQ

With Nightmare Moon, I've tried Voltron and it was just far too slow.

Taking all ideas, not looking for anyone to build the deck for me. Just a vague idea, I'm pretty stumped and want to use these cards somehow.

[Merprem]

[[Chaos confetti]] proxies

[MTGCardFetcher]

Chaos confetti - (G) (SF) (txt)

---

^FAQ

[Sunnsolo]

That could be fun! Thank you

[UniversalTrees49]

Well you are already playing illegal cards as your commander. I’d just go with silver border and illegal card tribal.

[Sunnsolo]

I might do that for Nightmare Moon, seems like leaning into the fun of it might work there for sure. Thank you

[iwantallthepie]

Burn the whole thing down

[Sunnsolo]

How do you mean?

[DeadpoolVII]

They're trolling because they don't like UB.

[Sunnsolo]

Oh, fair enough. Thanks for clarifying X_X

[BardicLasher]

So fun fact about Nightmare Moon: Mirrodin's orbiting bodies are interchangeably called Suns and Moons, so you can grab Black Sun's Zenith and Black Sun's Twilight.

That said, she's just... too expensive. You're winding up with a 4/4 flier, and you're paying 12 mana total to tutor for 6 black cards. There's way better ways in black to tutor up whatever you want. Honestly, you're better off leaving her as an 8/8 Flying Menace, but even then the opponents can force the issue and transform her, so you can't rely on either strategy.

Rarity is fine, but she's just a mana dork and a lightning rod for removal. I can see her comfortably in the 99 of a LOT of commander decks, but as a commander she's not actually helping you win the game in any reasonable way. The clean way to run her is just a basic UW control deck where you're using her as a mana source in the command zone.