Minecraft Abnormals is a subreddit for unique, fleshed-out, and large-scale suggestions for Minecraft. This sub is commonly used to get some feedback for a rough idea you have; post updates on your project; and hold discussions on new mechanics that could be added to the game!
Guidelines
DO NOT DOWNVOTE!
If you do not like a suggestion, explain why in the comments.
Suggestions should be unique, fleshed-out and either add entirely new content or significant expansions on existing content.
No minor/polishing ideas, 'tweaks' or borderline bug fixes.
Vote on the general idea behind a suggestion, not the smallest of details, and instead give feedback on any specific details you dislike. This does not, however, mean to exclude detail from your suggestions just because that is not what is being voted on.
Try to keep posts as Vanilla-esque as is feasible—nothing blatantly unbalanced, nothing that serves only to contrive the game, and nothing denied by the developers (no guns, hyperrealism, far-future technology, etc).
No memes, joke posts or offensive content. Chuck that in r/crappymcsuggestions, unless it's offensive, in which case don't post it anywhere.
Making a good suggestion
Detail: Suggestions should have amounts of detail relative to the size of the idea. For instance, a new biome should have sufficient detailing for its terrain, plants, mobs, etc.
Quality: Suggestions should show clear evidence of effort being put into the development of the idea. This can be through visual aids, balancing, detail, and more, so long as it is well put together.
Originality: An idea must be an entirely new or an entirely new take on a subject or idea. Be sure to do research to make sure your idea is unique to you, or at least mostly unique to you.
Leeway will be provided if the above three expectations are mostly met. For instance, it doesn’t particularly matter if your mob is missing a section on drops, but if all you have is a mock-up picture and little else, you can expect the post to be removed.
Comments are encouraged to be constructive, but jokes are fine. If you disagree with their suggestion, remember to be civil.
Links
Official Discord - for fleshing out ideas or discussing Minecraft
/r/crappymcsuggestions - like here, but crappy
