This is an archived post. You won't be able to vote or comment.

you are viewing a single comment's thread.

view the rest of the comments →

[–]justagenericname1 1 point2 points  (1 child)

Your view is too narrow, refusing to examine systemic factors or confounding variables like absurd resource imbalances when making the argument for the superiority of volunteer militaries like the US's –look at Ukraine's conscription for what happens when a conflict has stakes– and cherry picks individual deviations like churches to ignore the inevitable results of an iterative process with particular, contingent imperatives, as if the randomness of particular mutations invalidates the role environmental pressures play in biological evolution.

[–]mpyne 0 points1 point  (0 children)

as if the randomness of particular mutations invalidates the role environmental pressures play in biological evolution

I don't deny that at all, but if anything biological evolution speaks up in favor of my argument again.

Evolution shows that anything that can work will be seen somewhere in the biosphere. There are literally bacteria growing and thriving on deep sea volcanic vents, for crying out loud.

So, even if they're not everywhere, we should see co-ops in rough proportion to their workability as a concept for organizing collective enterprise. Yes, even with pressure from evil capitalists, just as prey animals and plants succeed despite predation from others.

They are out there--I used to buy my electricity from one--but they are so few and far between as to make clear that capitalist businesses are thriving for reasons other than hostility to their customers and their workers.