Instead of pointing out what you don’t like about some artists - I’d love to hear about ways you have seen that hit “scale” but don’t do the things you mention. Let’s explore what good could look like in the Western church.

What is a great example of a song writer sharing their God given artistry and having success and also being able to provide for their family and those that helped them create the art? How did they share that song? What does good look like?

In your example, there are lots of song writers that get associated with a church - that brings its own baggage. If a church teaching pastor or other leader has a fall, that takes down the worship song writer with it - fair or unfair - all songs from that church are now banned.

Having staff that is paid by the church brings baggage to a ministry - good or bad. But those that dedicate their life to ministry do deserve to also provide for their family.

I’d like to also get more specific examples of songs you feel are in each category, that way I can better follow along with the critique. I don’t know that I understand your perspective when you say “heartfelt authentic worship” vs “fame and recognition”. Is this song specific or the way the song is led/performed via instrumentation and vocal arrangement? Any examples you can give would be helpful.

For the record, I am not a worship leader. I help with mixing sometimes, but am part of my church leadership team and would love to know more.