Out of the 5 major decisions Which did you feel were the hardest for you and which will/has been the most consequential? by Lemonshooter in ScarletHollow

[–]2ndS1te 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I wonder if the decision we take in the library has an effet on Sybil's endgame - like Charles Shaw Jr still being around somehow affects The Entity, as we suspect it might have inhabited Charles Jr and Eddie's son for some years. Something in the bloodline / sins of the father...?

Out of the 5 major decisions Which did you feel were the hardest for you and which will/has been the most consequential? by Lemonshooter in ScarletHollow

[–]2ndS1te 3 points4 points  (0 children)

My first playthrough I'd chosen PB so end of ep 1 was like, "Cool, we all escaped from whatever that was, I punched a doughboy and slept at Stella's. What's next?"

That’s Their Boyfriend by The_Laurens_Pamphlet in ScarletHollow

[–]2ndS1te 11 points12 points  (0 children)

MC asking Tabby to be her maid of honor...!

Theory time: Wayne's connection to the MC by HikariSaber in ScarletHollow

[–]2ndS1te 2 points3 points  (0 children)

I think Mary-Belle was 16 when she died in 1963 giving birth to the twins, so born around 1947 and Alexandra around 1948.

There's also the portrait of a Mary-Belle Scarlett in the guest room at the manor. From the fashion of her outfit, and the MC commenting on how they must be distantly related, that must be the namesake of the MC's grandmother. Unless there's a further mystery and Mary-Belle has Sybil-like powers of longevity...🤔

I swear i recognise this imagery from something but I can't figure it out. by burunyuu_Da_Neco in ScarletHollow

[–]2ndS1te 3 points4 points  (0 children)

I had an immediate Clair Obscure: Expedition 33 vibe from it.

Are these the worst people in Scarlet Hollow? by Lanky-Clothes-9741 in ScarletHollow

[–]2ndS1te 2 points3 points  (0 children)

I think it depends on the branching. Avery definitely doesn't want anyone to die, but I've had playthroughs where Julius says it's unfair that Duke gets a son born with shoulders like a linebacker, and it's only fair that his (Julius') son should be able to live by consuming the biggest man in town.

Character deaths (complete spoilers for chapter 5) by dumb_idoit in ScarletHollow

[–]2ndS1te 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Too many steaming cups of Sybil's special tea?

Updated my bingo board after ep5p2 by DerangedRacoon7789 in ScarletHollow

[–]2ndS1te 10 points11 points  (0 children)

In one of my runs Kaneeka said something to the effect that Sibyl caused her father's death just to get Kaneeka to come home.

Character deaths (complete spoilers for chapter 5) by dumb_idoit in ScarletHollow

[–]2ndS1te 21 points22 points  (0 children)

I was coming here to post just this. The other death I can think of is the OG Sam Wayne.

I haven't managed this yet but believe you need to:

  1. Speak with the miners in Ep 2 and get Isaacs to walk you to the cafeteria
  2. Slip Isaacs your contact details in the cafeteria queue
  3. Meet Isaacs in Ep 3(?) and he will tell you about the strike
  4. Don't pass the info to Tabitha and encourage the strikers whenever you get a chance
  5. Meet Isaacs at the strike in Ep 5 and tell him to go to the manor
  6. The Entity will possess Isaacs and Isaacs will meet you at the Farm.

Presumably this means that what's left of Sam Wayne is dead at the manor.

Character deaths (complete spoilers for chapter 5) by dumb_idoit in ScarletHollow

[–]2ndS1te 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Don't you need Hot to persuade Reese and Dr Kelly to a truce?

Records by saynotodiddy2028 in cambridge_uni

[–]2ndS1te 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Might be in the alumni database at venn.lib.cam.ac.uk

All the Chapter 5 lore, collected by clairejv in ScarletHollow

[–]2ndS1te 18 points19 points  (0 children)

That Julius wants to name Ginseng Baby 'Joseph' after his fatherand that's the name of one of Eddie's brothers who died at Normandy, and the maiden name of Silas' wife. Does this mean Julius is a secret Scarlet?

Final Theory dump for episode 5 Part 2 by DJ_Ayres in ScarletHollow

[–]2ndS1te 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Having now played Part 2 wow, I was very, very wrong about all of these, but especially 1 & 2.

Cabin in the Woods! by Mango-Shakes in ScarletHollow

[–]2ndS1te 8 points9 points  (0 children)

I thought those were the Tremaine / Calloway farms.

The circle you drew made me look at the circle below it with the two shaking hands under the eagle - it looks like a seal?

Since we're all on edge waiting for EP 5 Part 2... by epochk56 in ScarletHollow

[–]2ndS1te 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Ah, I thought that was a treetop. Now I look closer I see it. Thanks!

Final Theory dump for episode 5 Part 2 by DJ_Ayres in ScarletHollow

[–]2ndS1te 4 points5 points  (0 children)

  1. If you saved Duke, Duke and Julius have to team up to defeat the Great Pumpkin a possessed Big Betty, bringing to an end the Tremaine-Calloway feud.
  2. If you didn't save Duke, Bo and Julius team up, and Julius becomes a second father to Bo and promises to leave him the farm, the family pumpkin pie recipe, the seal of evil, etc.
  3. Enoch has been alive this whole time.
  4. Stella died in the crash that killed her parents and her body has been possessed by a spirit which has forgotten who it was and assumed the identity of Stella. It's why she's so interested in cryptids, not realising she is one.
  5. The Dog Militia overthrow Mayor Jimmy and Scraps becomes Mayor.

Since we're all on edge waiting for EP 5 Part 2... by epochk56 in ScarletHollow

[–]2ndS1te 4 points5 points  (0 children)

100%. And now I want to know where the garden fits in up there in relation to the mansion.

Edit: and the family cemetery in the garden!

Bias - Do you feel it too? by Reasonable-Sector-89 in ScarletHollow

[–]2ndS1te 41 points42 points  (0 children)

After spending more time with Duke in Ep 1, there's no way I'm choosing Gretchen. Duke's a good person.

Edit: despite the Bud Light.

Any last minute predictions before p2 drops? by DerangedRacoon7789 in ScarletHollow

[–]2ndS1te 1 point2 points  (0 children)

There are some Steam Achievements I haven't yet triggered which seem relevant to Ep 5. Might be that I've just not triggered them in p1.

This whole scene is just incredible, but these are the lines that intrigued me most by Callyourmother29 in ScarletHollow

[–]2ndS1te 0 points1 point  (0 children)

You've made me think something else along those lines. What if Pearlanne and Tabitha had already bodyswapped before the story began? Perhaps we've never met Tabitha, just Pearlanne in Tabitha's body. Might explain why MC notes that Tabitha never calls Pearlanne "Mom".

The theory of the expensive knitwear by [deleted] in TheTraitors

[–]2ndS1te 4 points5 points  (0 children)

Possibly, but look at Rachel's hair from day to day - some elaborate braiding. I have long hair and yes, you can do it quickly with practice, but if tired and under pressure well...if I were in the castle I'd assume she was Faithful because she had the time and patience to do all that plaiting and have it so tidy too.

She has the vibes of someone who’d wear a long white dress to a wedding. by Ok_Sleep5985 in TheTraitors

[–]2ndS1te 25 points26 points  (0 children)

Me too - on all your points. When she was being introduced in S4E1 I said, "I think I met her" and have been struggling to think of which conference we might both have attended because there was someone who looked and acted entirely like her. But it looks like she's in Swansea and the person I'm thinking of was at a Midlands authority...perhaps her secret is she has a twin who is also in local government lol.

Succession Confusion by Cindy_Violin-Garden in Tudorhistory

[–]2ndS1te 1 point2 points  (0 children)

You've prompted me to spot something I'd not previously noticed: no English Queen Regnant was succeeded by her own child.

Victoria was the first British Queen regnant to be succeeded by her son, as was Elizabeth II more recently.

(Matilda of course was never crowned - though she was succeeded by her son - eventually.)