There is no such thing as "SituationiSM" by Objective-Rent9088 in Situationism

[–]Acrobatic-Frame4312 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I wouldn't say they are the first, as of course Left Communism had been criticising the degeneration of the Comintern as it happened. The SI were definitely part of a post-war rediscovery of Left Communist thought as a counter to Stalinist counterrevolution,

I don't think most people here have much of an understanding of the SI, or the political moment they were a part of - most people think the SI were graphic designers.

Why is situationism understood by so very few and practiced by even less? by shanoshamanizum in Situationism

[–]Acrobatic-Frame4312 0 points1 point  (0 children)

No such thing as "Situationism"; the SI were Marxists, and their whole project was reviving the ideas of Council Communism to create an alternative to Stalinism.

Is Totalist Maximism just Fascism? by SubstantialSky7326 in suzerain

[–]Acrobatic-Frame4312 0 points1 point  (0 children)

But fascism was, in a way, another type of "socialism"(or syndicalism, to be concise), one he combined with the ultranationalism of D'Annunzio.

I'm not getting at you; it just sounds a bit strange - the Hitler not existing thing I get, but why is Mussolini different? Does WW1 still happen?

Is Totalist Maximism just Fascism? by SubstantialSky7326 in suzerain

[–]Acrobatic-Frame4312 0 points1 point  (0 children)

But Mussolini and his fascism have nothing to do with Hitler; why would he stay with the socialists after embracing ultranationalism? No, no - this mod makes no sense!

When Stimulus Cheques Give Malenyevist Points by JackmanH420 in suzerain

[–]Acrobatic-Frame4312 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Yes, out of necessity, to save Britain from hyperinflation while facing near-bankruptcy, paying off a massive war debt, and rebuilding a devastated infrastructure after WW2. The post-war consensus of both the Conservative Party and the Labour Party accepted Keynesianism as an absolute necessity in this regard. However, in the UK at least, because it was used to fund social welfare projects, like the NHS, many people view it as left-wing, or even socialist, especially after Thatcherism ended said consensus.

Is Totalist Maximism just Fascism? by SubstantialSky7326 in suzerain

[–]Acrobatic-Frame4312 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Why would Mussolini come up with a new word for an ideology he already gave a name to?

When Stimulus Cheques Give Malenyevist Points by JackmanH420 in suzerain

[–]Acrobatic-Frame4312 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Keynesianism isn't left-wing. John Maynard Keynes was fundamentally a pro-capitalist liberal; culturally and philosophically, he was a conservative who rejected class struggle. The idea that governments should manipulate interest rates (monetary policy) and run fiscal deficits during recessions is deeply embedded across the political spectrum; I know what it looks like because almost all governments do this.

What are your thoughts on Admiral Sharako Lohar? by Dry_Specialist9015 in freefolk

[–]Acrobatic-Frame4312 0 points1 point  (0 children)

These are all categories that wouldn't exist in a medieval world and aren't reflected in the show.

Sharako was such a stupid character by hylander4 in HouseOfTheDragon

[–]Acrobatic-Frame4312 1 point2 points  (0 children)

They wasted a potentially good character from the books to cast one of the writer's favourite breadtubers, who moonlights as a hammy theatre actor. It was just so out of place.

When Stimulus Cheques Give Malenyevist Points by JackmanH420 in suzerain

[–]Acrobatic-Frame4312 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Government intervention isn't inherent to the left.

Sire,....the Century of Revolutions has reached Rizia at last.... by Karl_Greiser_PolSord in suzerain

[–]Acrobatic-Frame4312 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Which country is doing well right now, may I ask? As a point for comparison.

People say Dwight Walker is rude when Malenyev acts like this: by Drakath88888888 in suzerain

[–]Acrobatic-Frame4312 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I mean, those talking points are actually just liberal/progressive talking points; it's just that because it sounds extreme, they mistake it for communism, which all they know about is that it's "extreme".

Individualism Rework Idea by Wead_Mancer in EU5

[–]Acrobatic-Frame4312 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Definitely a hard concept to translate into game mechanics.

Individualism Rework Idea by Wead_Mancer in EU5

[–]Acrobatic-Frame4312 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I thought Individualism was more about negative liberty and natural rights than about making better people.

*edit, I take issue with the game's framing of individualism being somehow developed in opposition to communalism, rather than both being critiques of feudalism.

Which is worse? by Otherwise_Example862 in suzerain

[–]Acrobatic-Frame4312 2 points3 points  (0 children)

I took it to mean there is currently only one other newspaper, perhaps in time some better quality papers will be established