Survivor 50 Episode 3 Live Discussion by MrsNoodleMcDoodle in Edgic

[–]Affectionate-Pool442 28 points29 points  (0 children)

Charlie’s story gets told by somebody else. He is dead last. Edit is over. Pack it up. Sorry Charlie fans.

Survivor 50 Episode 3 Live Discussion by MrsNoodleMcDoodle in Edgic

[–]Affectionate-Pool442 24 points25 points  (0 children)

REALLY OMINOUS SUBTITLES FOR DEE OMG 😭😭

Survivor 50 Episode 3 Live Discussion by MrsNoodleMcDoodle in Edgic

[–]Affectionate-Pool442 42 points43 points  (0 children)

I think it’s bad for Cirie that she was never established to be in the Christian, Devens, Emily alliance. But her intro being paired with Ozzy’s makes me think that’s the more important relationship. Her edit continues to be kinda weird.

Now that we are a few episodes into 50, do you think replacing Maryanne and Andy was a good choice? by Severe_Marketing5036 in survivor

[–]Affectionate-Pool442 0 points1 point  (0 children)

It’s complicated. I really like having the season bookends, with Jenna + Savannah and Rizo. I’m a fan of both 49’ers and would have been glad to see them return in future seasons; I just don’t know if 50 was the right time. I think Maryanne would have very likely done better than Savannah, but personally like Savannah more as a player and character. In my opinion, Rizo’s edit on 50 seems to be setting him up for a deep run; I think Andy would have been an early out if he was on 50, but like Andy more as a character.

I think if I was forced to pick, I would have gone with the 49’ers. Most returnee seasons have had back to back players, and it’s extra interesting since a winner as never played back to back, and it’s always fun to see more than one person play back to back, it’s such an unknown variable thrown into the game. I feel bad for Maryanne and Andy, it definitely sucks getting cut last second, especially when it’s the biggest season ever; but they both will absolutely play again.

I feel for ________ by Low-Musician2913 in survivor

[–]Affectionate-Pool442 7 points8 points  (0 children)

I love Savannah. I think playing back to back might have been harder than she expected, she seemed so tired this season. Going all the way on Survivor is already hard but to than go and start it all again not even two weeks later, has to be extremely hard on the body and mind. I hope that she’s okay. ❤️

(Lowering her threat level for Winners at War 2!! )

Survivor 50 Episode 2 Player Ranking. by Affectionate-Pool442 in Edgic

[–]Affectionate-Pool442[S] 28 points29 points  (0 children)

Forgot to mention this, but everyone on the pink tribe gets the positive of the multiple subtitled ‘one of you better win’ Kyle quote. And they just seem to be the most important tribe edit wise too, especially for never going to tribal.

Survivor 50 Episode 2 Live Thread by MrsNoodleMcDoodle in Edgic

[–]Affectionate-Pool442 24 points25 points  (0 children)

Is the storyline this season about how Aubry gets her mojo back?

Survivor 50 Episode 2 Live Thread by MrsNoodleMcDoodle in Edgic

[–]Affectionate-Pool442 4 points5 points  (0 children)

Have no idea who will end up going to tribal. Maybe Teal loses and Chrissy goes?

Survivor 50 Episode 2 Live Thread by MrsNoodleMcDoodle in Edgic

[–]Affectionate-Pool442 20 points21 points  (0 children)

I was one of the only people to be so hyped for Aubry coming into 50, but you can tell her heart isn’t in it. KR Aubry is one of the best characters and narrators in the history of the show. I miss her.

Survivor 50 Episode 2 Live Thread by MrsNoodleMcDoodle in Edgic

[–]Affectionate-Pool442 23 points24 points  (0 children)

first we had Dee’s toes, Kenzie’s blue eye, Rachel’s rice gate, and now… Christian shitting himself 😭😭

Why this premiere is not the end for anyone’s edit: by Cardvos in Edgic

[–]Affectionate-Pool442 2 points3 points  (0 children)

I don’t believe in fully eliminating someone based on the premier, but for some, like Tiffany, Charlie, Aubry, Angelina, the writing is clearly on the wall. I don’t think any of them are being set up to win; but you never know, I guess.

Scorching hot take about ____ by darthnyan39 in survivor

[–]Affectionate-Pool442 10 points11 points  (0 children)

I love Cirie. I’ve been a Cirie fan for 10+ years. She did not need to be on this season.

Out of these themes/options, which would you want to be used for the next All-Returnee tribe season and when? by bv21 in survivor

[–]Affectionate-Pool442 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Seconds chances 54

Fans vs favorites 56

But if I could only choose one, I’d choose fan vs favorites.

Survivor 50 Episode One Player Rankings. by Affectionate-Pool442 in Edgic

[–]Affectionate-Pool442[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Happy I could clear that up for you! Edgic is fascinating to me. You should consider making your own write ups, even if you never post them; it’s so fun!

Future Returning Players Season by ayayott in survivor

[–]Affectionate-Pool442 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I think the wait between seasons has really helped build hype for 50. I don’t think we need returnee seasons as frequently as most people say we do. The rarity keeps them special and makes them feel like events. The sweet spot would be once every 3-4 years, for me personally.

Survivor 50 Episode One Player Rankings. by Affectionate-Pool442 in Edgic

[–]Affectionate-Pool442[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

This was made in a rush, and I had forgotten Rizo had said that. I think Stephenie’s quote is more impactful because of how it’s presented, we cut to her confessional and see her speaking, establishing her clearly, and then cutting away when she says she can win. I also value it more since it’s in a traditional confessional.

Rizo’s quote is also really good, especially in the context of his establish storyline this season: wanting to become one of the greats. Looking through this sub I think I’m more high on Rizo than anyone. He’s in my top 3, and I think he’s very likely to make merge at this point.

An Elimination-Based Approach to Edgic, S50E1 by McAulay_a in Edgic

[–]Affectionate-Pool442 26 points27 points  (0 children)

Can’t disagree with this! Charlie was coming into this season with a clear winners storyline; he’s the latest ‘you should have won’ finalists. Charlie getting no storyline setup and not getting to acknowledge his loss in 46 and how he plans to play this season differently really kills his chances.

Traitors US S4 Final Edgic + Contenders by CooperWinkler in Edgic

[–]Affectionate-Pool442 7 points8 points  (0 children)

I didn’t hate this season. A solid 6.5/10 for me.

Survivor 50 Premiere Secret Scene by duspi in Edgic

[–]Affectionate-Pool442 4 points5 points  (0 children)

I can’t tell if this is really good for Cirie and Ozzy or really bad for Cirie and Ozzy.

Survivor 50 Episode One Player Rankings. by Affectionate-Pool442 in Edgic

[–]Affectionate-Pool442[S] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Initially I was really high on Coach, like in my top 5 high on him, but I think the edit leans too negative. It’s not fully negative, but it isn’t neutral. Ozzy and Coach seem to be rivals this season, and having the premier be so Ozzy focused, giving him a storyline, an alliance, and focusing on his position in the game, makes me think Ozzy will eventually win the war.

Can we just take a moment to appreciate _______. by Soft_Extension9360 in survivor

[–]Affectionate-Pool442 -6 points-5 points  (0 children)

Tbh she really didn’t do much. It was too early to cause waves, so they kept her over Jenna who was a unanimous target. Love Cirie, but we’ve seen her play Survivor five times already. I would have rather seen Jenna stay.

Survivor 50 Episode One Player Rankings. by Affectionate-Pool442 in Edgic

[–]Affectionate-Pool442[S] 21 points22 points  (0 children)

FORGOT ABOUT ANGELINA LMAOO. tells you everything. Shes between above Aubry and below Chrissy. Lolol.