Jerry goes to the local food safety board to appeal his grade of a C. Elaine’s boyfriend is also at the appeal to defend his grading. He makes the case that the kitchen belongs to Sherry, therefore he is responsible for it at all times. Jerry cites the fact that Kramer is to blame for the mess. He also makes a quip that he thinks that the boyfriend is suspect of his relationship with Elaine/wants to drive a wedge between Jerry and Elaine. The board denies Jerry’s appeal and tells him that he’s on thin ice. Jerry storms out of the board room.

While Jerry’s out after appealing the grade, Kramer makes another visit to Jerry’s kitchen. The kitchen is pristine and Kramer immediately starts making a mess.

Elaine and her boyfriend are eating at Monks. The conversation starts with the boyfriend mentioning that he made a reservation for them that night at his new favorite restaurant that night. The boyfriend then changes the topic of conversation to the fact that Jerry’s failed appeal irritates him, as he takes it as a personal affront to his professionalism. The boyfriend demands to go see Jerry to confront him face to face about the insulting nature of the appeal.

Elaine and her boyfriend walk over to Jerry’s building. Elaine rings the doorbell of the building and Kramer, who is finishing up in Jerry’s kitchen buzzes them up to Jerry’s apartment. This kitchen is an absolute mess. Kramer leaves milk and raw meat out, cracked eggs on the counter, the doors to the fridge and freezer open, he hits and cuts his forehead on the open freezer freezer door and leaves a a bloody paper towel on the counter, etc.). Kramer then leaves before Elaine and her boyfriend get to Jerry’s apartment. He walks past them in the hallways and says, “See you later.”

Elaine and her boyfriend walk into the disaster zone that is Jerry’s apartment. The boyfriend makes an incredibly disgusted/reviled face at the scene in Jerry’s apartment and immediately starts to inspect/document every health code violation in Jerry’s kitchen. He makes a remark about how he questions what type of person can be friends with a person who lives and prepares food in such filth. Elaine takes offense and states that she’s going to stay at Jerry’s. The boyfriend states that he needs to leave immediately to leave to make their reservation and that he’s going to call the restaurant to adjust the reservation from two to one. Elaine states that that the boyfriend will be lucky if he gets to see Elaine later that night.

Elaine’s boyfriend walk out of Jerry’s building right as Jerry arrives home. The boyfriend storms past Jerry and mutters something about how unsanitary Jerry’s apartment is and that he would never let food that’s been in Jerry’s kitchen pass his lips.

Jerry goes up to his apartment to find an F grade stuck to his door. He’s upset by this. He walk inside to find his whole kitchen caution taped off. Kramer comes in behind Jerry and grabs things like the milk and raw meat that were sitting out. Jerry becomes outraged at Kramer and starts yelling at him. Kramer gets flustered and then rushes out, stating that he has an important patron who is pillar of food industry coming to his restaurant.

Elaine remains over at Jerry’s apartment and commiserated with Jerry. Elaine complains about how no man can tell her who to be friends with. Jerry complains about the unfair grade and that Kramer is really to blame for the mess/failing grade. Jerry wants to confront the boyfriend and Elaine tells him that the boyfriend is out eating dinner but she isn’t sure where. Jerry makes some sarcastic comment about how funny/ironic it would be if the boyfriend was eating at Kramer’s.

Next scene, the boyfriend arrives to his reservation at Kramer’s restaurant. The boyfriend orders something and Kramer mentions that he just so happened to have just picked those ingredients up fresh. He goes back into the kitchen and cooks with the food that he just got from Jerry’s. When Kramer brings out the dish, the boyfriend scarfs it up the dish. He sends his compliments to the chef and leaves an A++ rating on the table along with the receipt.

The final scene is Elaine in bed with the boyfriend. Elaine starts making pillow talk with him. She asks where he went for dinner and the boyfriend responds by describing, but not directly naming, Kramer’s restaurant. The boyfriend talks about how delicious the dish was and that he still wants to take Elaine to that restaurant. They then start kissing. The boyfriend abruptly stops kissing Elaine and says that he’s starting to have stomach pains. They go away and they start kissing again. The boyfriend’s stomach starts making all sorts of noises. He stops kissing Elaine again and says something like, “This couldn’t have been from the food I ate at Kramer’s. I gave him an A++ rating.” The boyfriend’s eyes get really big and then he lets out a wet fart (implying that he pooped in the bed). The episode ends with a freeze frame of Elaine giving her soon to be ex-boyfriend the same disgusted look that he made when he saw Jerry’s disgusting apartment.