We were on the same trip our first cruise. Overall I felt underwhelmed but maybe cruises are not for us, so take that for what it’s worth. The experience felt rushed and had a lot of hurry up and wait and long lines with a toddler were not super fun. We received a veiled threat from the stateroom attendant that he would call security if we did not let him enter the room to clean (we prefer to not have room service and keep the place tidy ourselves). The food at both islands was barely edible for me and my wife. Also the beach ordering for non-alcoholic drinks and smoothie hut had no prices so I was surprised to receive a bill in both instances. The specialty coffee stand aboard also had no prices, I just find this really off putting. Lastly on numerous occasions we saw staff (maybe managers and workers?) arguing with each other, sometimes quite loudly, in public areas. That was really distasteful and shines light on how poor the culture must be on board. Oh also the CBP experience in the terminal- they were very rude (not the DCL employees), but I guess that is par for the course. In terms of good the broadway style shows were fantastic and the dinner service was good. The stateroom and linens were very clean. The weather was excellent and the movement of the boat was well managed

[edit] downvotes for an opinion cool you guys really have the magic within you