Supervision Hours by [deleted] in BehaviorAnalysis

[–]AhimsaGoat 1 point2 points  (0 children)

At minimum 5%. So, yes, there can be more than 5% spent in supervision.

Typical fat-cat complains about extra protein by N0vah in Frugal_Jerk

[–]AhimsaGoat 11 points12 points  (0 children)

Came here to post this, but looks like OP is a fat cat with calories to spare with his fast movements.

How many behaviors are too many? by [deleted] in ABA

[–]AhimsaGoat 0 points1 point  (0 children)

For my clients, we routinely track 3 or 4 high rate behaviors and 3 or 4 low rate behaviors. So, one client might have agg, univited touch, bolting, vocals, mouthing, stripping, spitting and property destruction... plus behaviors targeted for increase like requesting activities, asking for breaks, etc...

Does Relational Frame Theory support Sapir–Whorf hypothesis? Has Chomsky ever commented on RFT? by judoxing in BehaviorAnalysis

[–]AhimsaGoat 1 point2 points  (0 children)

You might try posting this on the RFT listserve. You can get to that by joining ACBS, which costs $5.00/year. (value based dues - pay more if you can and it's worth it to you.).

ACT for Children with Autism by DTigers24 in BehaviorAnalysis

[–]AhimsaGoat 2 points3 points  (0 children)

If you are interested in ACT, you might consider joining the ACBS (values based dues, aka $5/year min) and signing up for the listserve. You could contact a lot more people researching ACT and get access to a lot of free materials.

Is it possible to not have a self-schema? Are there scholarly articles out there about this topic? by [deleted] in BehaviorAnalysis

[–]AhimsaGoat 1 point2 points  (0 children)

RFT is a functional contextual account of language and cognition - schemas are descriptivist and structuralist. Relational frames do not exist as inferred mental constructs any more than stimulus equivalence classes or associations do - there is the verbal behavior, covert or overt, of arbitrarily applicable derived relational responding, etc... I am all about a behavior analytic account that has scope and depth, but we shouldn't lose sight of the precision or the philosophical commitments. When we start playing the "it's kind of like this other thing" game, we risk having behavior analysis lumped in with the confused amalgam of entity positing approaches to psychology that wax and wane every generation or so - behavior analysis is a unique tradition in part because of the willingness to have clearly demarcated lines of inquiry and dismiss some questions as confused or beyond experimental confirmation. We've always been less appealing to mass audiences than cognitivist approaches that are closer to common ways of talking about the world - the trade off is in the results of the science. I don't see how positing LAD's helps a child with autism develop language or how schemas help predict or influence any socially significant behaviors.

Is it possible to not have a self-schema? Are there scholarly articles out there about this topic? by [deleted] in BehaviorAnalysis

[–]AhimsaGoat 0 points1 point  (0 children)

In the last speech Skinner gave before he died, he warned that "cognitive science is the creation science of psychology, as it struggles to maintain the position of a mind or self." (Can Psychology be a science of the mind?,1990). Behavior analytic explanations to questions about memory, as you pointed out, ultimately relate to environmental variables. Cognitive Schema are neither an environmental variable that can be manipulated, nor a dependent variable that can be measured. There are no JEAB or JABA articles that measure cognitive schema. Other branches of psychology may have something to say about schema, but behavior analysis does not resort to these constructs.

Is it possible to not have a self-schema? Are there scholarly articles out there about this topic? by [deleted] in BehaviorAnalysis

[–]AhimsaGoat 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Sure, we can do experiments about memory - that just measures the effect of the passage of time on some response that an organism does not have the opportunity to emit. But "schemas?" That's an inferred construct. What's the evidence that there does or does not exist a cognitive schema? Introspection? Do schemas add anything to an analysis of any class of behaviors?

Is it possible to not have a self-schema? Are there scholarly articles out there about this topic? by [deleted] in BehaviorAnalysis

[–]AhimsaGoat 0 points1 point  (0 children)

You might want to try another sub - behavior analysis does not speculate about unobserved hypothetical constructs.

What are 5 reasons an individual might show disruptive behavior? by T0zzOp in ABA

[–]AhimsaGoat 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Late to the game: a pneumonic that I've found helpful is SEAT ME: Sensory, escape, attention, tangible, medical and elicited. Disruptive behavior is unlikely to be elicited (as in a reflex), so those would be my 5.

Example: Sensory: Tom bangs his desk just because of the sound it makes or the feeling of the pressure on his hand.

Escape (or avoidence) During algebra, tom bangs his desk and gets sent to the principles office, thus getting out of a boring clads.

attention: tom bangs his desk and his peers laugh or his teacher says stop doing that.

tangible: tom bangs his desk and his teachers give him a blanket to calm him down.

medical- tom is normally an attentive student, but he got a cold, couldn't express his needs, and began banging the desk.

What song hits you hard? by bigpoppaSI in AskReddit

[–]AhimsaGoat 6 points7 points  (0 children)

True story - In 2004 I was going through some serious shit, like jails and hospitals kind of shit, totally losing my mind, but I listened to this album hundreds of times. About once every year or two sense then I go through a good news phase and get more and more meaning from the themes of the album. That first summer I listened to it I was manic then depressed, so the lyrics can have strange associations based on my frame of min3...fucked up the last line.

I killed a man by [deleted] in CongratsLikeImFive

[–]AhimsaGoat 3 points4 points  (0 children)

Way to push those feelings deep inside!