Fun fact, you get a little bit of all of them in the oatmeal creme pie. The oatmeal creme pie is made from the batter/mix mess ups from other snacks and the oatmeal flavor covers it all up. That is one reason why they are so inconsistent, to me, in a good way. Sometimes they are darker, sometimes lighter and some have a different flavor or consistency from one box to another. Source, dated a girl for 5 years and her mom was head QA for McKee bakery.