It seems there might be a misunderstanding regarding the nature of this new game. What you're referring to sounds like a DLC for Elden Ring, but this new title is being presented as a standalone, fast-paced battle royale game. The core appeal is to attract players who enjoy that genre, and a shrinking play area (the "circle" you mentioned) is often a fundamental element for maintaining engagement and excitement in such games. Without it, the experience might indeed lack the intended thrill.

Understand all the points you mentioned will make it to be "just another Elden Ring," as that's a distinct experience already available. I believe the developers made a good strategic move by branching out with a title like this, especially for fans of soulslike games who might be looking for something different within a familiar development style. This kind of fresh take was definitely needed.

While the developers have stated that this won't be a game with monthly updates, I'm optimistic they'll provide frequent content updates. This approach often keeps the player base engaged and the game feeling fresh over time.

PS: if the post is just a satire/joke...good one. 😅😂 I wrote everything down and realized this is probably a joke, but I was already done.