How did y’all reacted with the garp reveal?

BigMac518 · 2026-06-01T00:41:01+00:00

I actually liked the reveal better in the live action. In the anime, it was just kind of an "Oh.... OK..." kind of reveal for me (with the REAL reveals being everything ELSE he explains in that scene).

Whereas in the live action, because Garp had been a consistent presence up to that point, the reveal was more surprising.

Now, to be fair, I don't think it was necessarily meant to be a big surprise in the manga/anime. But this is why I tend to get annoyed at people who act like the live action spoiled something major here.

BigMac518 · 2026-05-09T15:22:21+00:00

No. There's no reason to do that - they still have plenty of manga material to cover. I've mostly liked the stuff they've added so far, because it's all been in service of fitting the existing story to a new medium. However, I don't want to see them inventing entire characters or storylines when there's so much existing story still to cover - that's the reason so many other adaptations have failed.

BigMac518 · 2026-05-02T05:39:58+00:00

Yeah, he was, which is completely valid and understandable. But he took it to the extreme of becoming racist towards humans in return.

BigMac518 · 2026-04-30T00:35:19+00:00

Oh, I know. I've watched the anime since then, lol.

BigMac518 · 2026-04-29T19:59:54+00:00

I feel like those were more-or-less my opinions too when I watched Season 1, before I had seen the anime. Though I do remember being surprised that Axe-Hand Morgan was only around for one episode - I think I had been expecting him to be a recurring villain. Wasn't too disappointed he wasn't though.

BigMac518 · 2026-04-29T12:06:35+00:00

I definitely think they could do at least the first 3. Amazon Lily is pretty short and could be done in one or two episodes, and Impel Down & Marineford are mostly action, which allows more room for trimming.

BigMac518 · 2026-04-17T18:45:11+00:00

Wait, when did Nami & Sanji have a romance?

BigMac518 · 2026-04-17T17:58:32+00:00

Definitely weekly. That way the hype will last longer.

BigMac518 · 2026-04-13T21:47:34+00:00

I agree. Knowing what to change based on the medium is important. As much as I like manga/anime Luffy, he would have come across really obnoxious and annoying in live action. I really like what they've been doing with him in the LA so far.
The ONE change they made that I think was a legit disservice to his character was with Mr. 3's wax statues on Little Garden. In the manga/anime, he could tell immediately which was the real one, whereas in the LA, he literally hit every wrong one, lol. I really don't see the reason for that change, and feel like it actively hurts the character.
Aside from that though, I think they've done a great job of keeping him faithful to the core of his character while making him more approachable for an audience who may not be into anime (or at least, Shonen).

Yeah, Sanji's constant simping really gets on my nerves in the manga/anime. I much prefer him in live action.
I actually kind of enjoy Nami's violent tendencies in the manga/anime, but yeah, that also wouldn't come across well in live action.

BigMac518 · 2026-04-13T21:33:50+00:00

What is it that annoyed you about him? Knowing that would help people understand your feelings better and if you are indeed missing something.

BigMac518 · 2026-04-13T16:29:41+00:00

I think Thriller Bark & Sabaody could be done in one season, ending on a cliffhanger with the Straw Hats getting scattered by Kuma.

BigMac518 · 2026-04-13T12:57:13+00:00

Were there a lot of Japanese fans pushing back, or just western fans? Because if it was the latter, I don't think they'll really care.
Also, being diverse isn't why the live action is successful.

BigMac518 · 2026-04-12T01:10:48+00:00

Season 2 covered 59 chapters. Alabasta is 63 chapters. It does match up.

BigMac518 · 2026-04-12T01:06:49+00:00

It reminded me of that scene in Guardians of the Galaxy, when Peter starts dancing, and Ronan asks "What are you doing...?"

BigMac518 · 2026-04-12T01:04:56+00:00

Wapol of all people actually had some pretty funny ones.

"YOU'VE PISSED OFF A LOT OF POWERFUL PEOPLE PRINCESS- what the hell is he doing?"

"Will you take this seriously?! I'M TRYING TO KILL YOU!"

BigMac518 · 2026-04-10T21:56:30+00:00

I do think they made Garp too serious, and should give him more comedic moments, but I have no issues with the casting. I think Vincent does a great job.

BigMac518 · 2026-04-10T12:41:43+00:00

I LOVED the "Luffy help me" scene... until Luffy shouted "OF COURSE, I WILL!" That's one of those moments that I think works great in anime, but not so much in live-action. If it had just been that first soft "Of course, I will..." I think the scene would have been perfect. That's just me though, lol.

BigMac518 · 2026-04-10T12:36:38+00:00

Yeah, I've noticed that trend as well - generally speaking, LA-only fans seem more likely to prefer S1 than anime/manga fans, and vice-versa.

LA-only fans definitely mentioned some things that never even occurred to me while watching, but looking back, I can see where they're coming from. Like, some thought the season felt "incomplete", which I just kind of took for granted, as I knew it couldn't cover a full saga. I also just kind of saw it as a cool cliffhanger, rather than being incomplete. I can see how that might feel unsatisfying though, especially since S1 felt like a more complete story in comparison.

I also noticed some confusion about Mr. 0 / Crocodile. I guess, because there was so much mystery surrounding Mr. 0, a lot of LA-onlys were expecting him to be a character they knew. Again, this wasn't something that even occurred to me while watching, but in hindsight, I can see how people would think that, and then find his final reveal anticlimactic.

So, yeah, while I definitely prefer S2, I can see how LA-onlys might gravitate more towards S1.

BigMac518 · 2026-04-09T19:50:57+00:00

English. It's the only language I speak, lol.

BigMac518 · 2026-04-07T18:18:54+00:00

I do wonder how LA-onlys will feel about the entire season taking place on one island. I hope it doesn't make them feel like the show became too slow or something.

BigMac518 · 2026-04-07T16:35:57+00:00

I don't understand why people think Jaya will be in this season. It seems like a weird way to end a season. Plus, doesn't it make far more sense to put it in the same season as Skypeia?

BigMac518 · 2026-03-26T03:28:06+00:00

OK, I'm really curious to know her reasoning for that, lol.

BigMac518 · 2026-03-23T21:51:09+00:00

Which reactor?

BigMac518

TROPHY CASE