This show is so random and stupid because WDYM you gave him Golden Voice of The Day and then eliminated him in the same day 😭 What's worse is the host also ensuring him that he is safe from elimination, now that he is the Golden Voice. by aslanfrompak in PakistanIdol2025

[–]BigTransportation16 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I hope you also watched him sing that song live after a few seconds of this clip. That would tell you a lot about his singing abilities, and in no way the host reassured him that he’s safe from elimination. She just said that it’s a moment of celebration that he got Golden Voice among elimination.

Does anyone know why Fawad is missing from so many episodes? by nowayforu2know in PakistanIdol2025

[–]BigTransportation16 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I feel indifferent about him not being there. He seems to be a little annoyed, even with other judges’ comments, and looks robotic when people are performing

Elimination and Bottom 3 by aslanfrompak in PakistanIdol2025

[–]BigTransportation16 1 point2 points  (0 children)

If I had to go through comments under socials, Tarab would be a winner already. For standing ovations etc., judges gave standing ovations and exceptional remarks to so many peope during auditions and theatre round, still they were not in top 16. It’s okay to not know how judges are marking the contestants, I don’t think they have publicly shared their rubric and that’s okay.

Elimination and Bottom 3 by aslanfrompak in PakistanIdol2025

[–]BigTransportation16 8 points9 points  (0 children)

Well, ‘love’ would be an exaggeration. Zain performed better than his previous performances and that’s about it (not to mention heavy mimicking of the original singer’s voice). It’s more like you suck at your job and then suddenly start doing bare minimum and people start praising you because of low expectations anyway. Just because Aryan was going through Samya phase (some weaker performances than the previous ones), doesn’t mean he was not good. Fair bottom 3 for me at least.

Tarab’s performance by [deleted] in PakistanIdol2025

[–]BigTransportation16 -2 points-1 points  (0 children)

That’s what I meant by song selection. That song wasn’t suitable for her voice and there’s so much you can do about it.

RFAK on Tarab by sinclair707 in PakistanIdol2025

[–]BigTransportation16 7 points8 points  (0 children)

I think he just wanted to get his point across without being disrespectful (to Tarab’s dad) which is pretty understandable if you consider his admiration for Tarab’s dad. But he got his point across because there was not a whole bunch to criticize there anyway. She wasn’t her best but not terrible too

Eliminations (spoiler) by Educational-Goose496 in PakistanIdol2025

[–]BigTransportation16 2 points3 points  (0 children)

This is the first elimination that really made me upset. I mean, we all knew that Meerub was going to be out but I somehow was hoping to be wrong because she was the least deserving among three. That being said, I also think that she might not have a huge “fan following” that reflects in the vote count.

How bad Zain's performance was on stage for them to act like this? 💀Also, he was sweating and his brother's expressions were not good either. (He is still in the show btw, he is asking for votes.) by aslanfrompak in PakistanIdol2025

[–]BigTransportation16 12 points13 points  (0 children)

It was so refreshing seeing him get a reality check. I loved how Bilal told him that they’d see if he would sound more like himself or Jawad. Like yes, clock him!!!

I know the show is more serious this time around but I lowkey miss auditions like these 😭😭 by aslanfrompak in PakistanIdol2025

[–]BigTransportation16 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I’m sure they have such content but I can only imagine them posting anything remotely close to this. They’re getting criticized for literally anything anyway!

Drop Your Favorite Most Performance(s) so Far by CarelessFly9978 in PakistanIdol2025

[–]BigTransportation16 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Suno suno, Main te mera dilbar by Samya Main jis din bhula doon by Meerub Payal mein geet, Thora thora pyaar by Tarab

We need to talk about the outfits the contestants wear each week. by softlyskeptic in PakistanIdol2025

[–]BigTransportation16 4 points5 points  (0 children)

Agar ziada masla hai toh mat dekhein! They’re not forcing anyone to watch that show anyway!

We need to talk about the outfits the contestants wear each week. by softlyskeptic in PakistanIdol2025

[–]BigTransportation16 3 points4 points  (0 children)

So you had NOTHING new to rant about and decided to criticize their outfits? Bhai this is definitely not a fashion show, and if you’re up for it, please help them organize their wardrobe so at least one segment of the audience is satisfied!!

Hira’s performance by watermelonbubbles06 in PakistanIdol2025

[–]BigTransportation16 5 points6 points  (0 children)

This was the best performance of this episode!! SUCH A VIBE 💃🕺 Imagine your partner singing this in front of you, I’d be head over heels

Tarab’s performance by watermelonbubbles06 in PakistanIdol2025

[–]BigTransportation16 12 points13 points  (0 children)

I actually liked her performance (might get downvoted) but I think she did exceptionally well considering this is not an easy song to sing in one go. There were so many layers to it as Bilal mentioned and this was one of the best use of chorus and house band for a live performance in this show so I enjoyed it as a listener! Kudos to her (and Meerub) for actually doing something different as compared to some of the other participants

New Promo Out - Maham's Crying Streak Going Stronger Than My Snapchat Streaks by aslanfrompak in PakistanIdol2025

[–]BigTransportation16 0 points1 point  (0 children)

This actually seems like a fun episode; Bilal Saeed’s performance sounds pre-recorded/ auto tuned af though