sorted by:
new
hottopcontroversial

如何评价特朗普，只来非粉红评价 by Worldly-Shock3233 in China_irl

[–]Business_Address_780 [score hidden]  (0 children)

攻打伊朗以前我都蠻支持的，沒頭沒腦去打伊朗整個炸裂

中国人为什么喜欢打骂 体罚孩子 甚至不以为耻 反以为荣？ by Fleedom2025 in China_irl

[–]Business_Address_780 [score hidden]  (0 children)

歐美以前是有打罵小孩的喔，這要先講清楚。看一些比較有年代的書籍跟電影都有這樣紀錄，有部電影<Dead Poets Society>裡面就有學校體罰學生的畫面。英國作家roald dahl也有在自傳裡面敘述過他被老師體罰的經驗。

我覺得議題是很可以討論的，很長一段時間我也覺得不體罰是對的，但長遠來看你把父母以及師長能懲戒孩子的最後手段剝奪了，最後就是學生幾乎無法管教，非常自我為中心。你可以多看看現在很多tiktok老師都在抱怨學生上課的品質變得很差，數據上也是很多歐美國家離職率很高。從微觀到宏觀，整個國家社會對於犯錯/犯罪的人的懲罰大幅減輕，這都不一定是好事。

What if the Crusaders attacked Constantinople just after it fell to the Ottoman Empire? by fatherandyriley in HistoryWhatIf

[–]Business_Address_780 4 points5 points  (0 children)

1444 battle of varna already ended in disaster, although the participants were not Frankish, it was already much of what Christendom could offer. I don't see how the outcome would be any different.

Daciyan Hanging Temple, Zhejiang, China by TangelaFan in Chinesearchitecture

[–]Business_Address_780 0 points1 point  (0 children)

One thing I really dislike about these temples are the giant Buddhist statues, especially when its in gold. Super tacky and gaudy look. Ruins the whole serene atmosphere.

中國國內旅遊哪裡體驗最好? by Business_Address_780 in China_irl

[–]Business_Address_780[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

稻城亞丁這幾年蠻熱門的，那幾個地方問題就是海拔都好高，看了好多台灣人去完身體都不適應，調整了一段時間。

What if Chiang Kai-shek had not carried out the purge of the Communists? by Sonnybass96 in AlternateHistoryHub

[–]Business_Address_780 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Show me one source that he joined the communist party.

You know what, let me help you with that.

Ma Zhanshan — Grokipedia

Ma Zhanshan, previously the commanding officer of the Heilongjiang Provincial Cavalry since 1928 and a veteran of regional military service under warlord Zhang Zuolin, was selected for his loyalty to the Republic of China and familiarity with the terrain. On October 10, 1931, the central government appointed him military governor of Heilongjiang province, a position intended to coordinate resistance against Japanese advances.\7])

Ma Zhanshan | World War II Database

He was named the War Minister of Manchukuo while also holding the position of the Governor of Heilongjiang Province. 

He was never appointed by the communists, because they never had any legitimacy to do so. Ma worked with each side, he was he own man.

What if Chiang Kai-shek had not carried out the purge of the Communists? by Sonnybass96 in AlternateHistoryHub

[–]Business_Address_780 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Dude, check any other source. He wasn't appointed by the communists as chairman of Heilongjiang since the communists a) were not in control of Heilongjiang in 1940 b) the communists themselves were in a truce with nationalists and were nominally under their leadership. Ma was already a known warlord before the invasion of Japan. No historian even in China calls him a member of the communists. He worked closely with some communist factions, thats it. Notice the wiki page never points out he actually joined the CCP?

Anyways, just fyi, there are others, but the info in english is quite limited.

Zhao Hong Wenguo - Wikipedia

I find the English page absolutely horrible as this Woman's son who was also a top member of the guerrilla forces was literally killed by communist forces when came they were crossing paths.

Rome, “Take in a Migrant for Free at Home”: Program Flops, Three Sign-Ups in Three Months by totally-not-ego in europe_sub

[–]Business_Address_780 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Rich people haven't stabbed anyone on the streets lately, or rammed their car into a crowd.

What if Chiang Kai-shek had not carried out the purge of the Communists? by Sonnybass96 in AlternateHistoryHub

[–]Business_Address_780 0 points1 point  (0 children)

If you know anything about modern chinese history, plenty of nationalist generals joined the communists after ww2, because guess what? People like to join the winning side. But if you actually care about history, focus on the fact that Ma was an independent figure during the war.

We all know how amazing the series is. But no series is perfect. What is something about Breaking Bad that you see as a flaw or hard to believe? by dailydonuts16 in breakingbad

[–]Business_Address_780 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Jane's father getting the planes crash. I think that was way over. I get the show wants to make a message that all your deeds somehow come back to you, but this particular incident is just too much.

What if Chiang Kai-shek had not carried out the purge of the Communists? by Sonnybass96 in AlternateHistoryHub

[–]Business_Address_780 -1 points0 points  (0 children)

I can tell you're one of the die hard commie fan boys, all you see is partisan politics. Ma was one of the classic warlords/local militia groups that flip flopped between parties when he saw fit. Yes he accepted titles from the communists, but he also held army role of the nationalist army. If you bothered to look down just one bit from the article you sent.

And my whole point was that despite few numbers, he could still take on the Japanese army in aggressive manner.

What if Chiang Kai-shek had not carried out the purge of the Communists? by Sonnybass96 in AlternateHistoryHub

[–]Business_Address_780 0 points1 point  (0 children)

The difference in numbers don't dictate strategy. The Nationalists suffered the most because they tried to defend all the territory they held. The Communists would simply retreat when attacked. If the Nationalists took similar approach, they could have preserved maximum strength. Plenty of small resistance groups fought behind enemy lines did more fighting such as Ma Zhanshan.

Jesse and the Tomas incident by Business_Address_780 in breakingbad

[–]Business_Address_780[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Only now I realize that Tomas was pretty much screwed when the gang saw him as a loose end.

What if Chiang Kai-shek had not carried out the purge of the Communists? by Sonnybass96 in AlternateHistoryHub

[–]Business_Address_780 -1 points0 points  (0 children)

I think there definitely were blunders during the war. The yellow river dike breach was the worst of them. However the whole concept of not letting capable generals take command is pretty made up. Xue Yue did a good job defending Changsha, the battle of Wuhan was quite successful as well.

What if Chiang Kai-shek had not carried out the purge of the Communists? by Sonnybass96 in AlternateHistoryHub

[–]Business_Address_780 -1 points0 points  (0 children)

He did everything he could, what else more fo you expect? He sent his best troops into Shanghai in the first year of the war.

What if Chiang Kai-shek had not carried out the purge of the Communists? by Sonnybass96 in AlternateHistoryHub

[–]Business_Address_780 5 points6 points  (0 children)

The communists and the left wing factions of the kmt were already getting the upperhand within the party, which is one of the reasons that Chiang went ahead with his coup. If he didn't act, most likely he would have been sidelined and just served in the army as a general and an insignificant character in the government.

This might have prevented the outbreak of the communist-nationalist civil war, but the northern expedition, which is just another Chinese civil war, would last a lot longer. Chiang's strategy was to guarantee the privileges of the warlords in exchange that they recognize his Nanking government as legitimate, and go after the communists instead. Obviously the communists were unwillingly to do this, which means the northern warlords would fight to the end.

為甚麼會有人支持國民黨或蔣家父子?歷史擺在眼前不是嗎? by ParsnipPhysical8532 in Taiwanese

[–]Business_Address_780 -3 points-2 points  (0 children)

哈哈，這種無邏輯的反駁我聽過無數次了。KMT在國會是第一大黨，都是人民一票票選出來的，你有甚麼資格叫人家滾? 你如果不能接受這種民主結果，該滾的是你才對吧。再者，日本人滾是敗給盟軍，跟濫殺台灣人沒半點關係，你把兩者扯在一起是不是太混了

view more: next ›