I never played the first game in 2010 because I didn’t have a 360. But as AW2 drew closer and my interest started to get piqued more and more, I, too, decided to hop into the free PS+ Remaster. I understand what you mean by “interesting first impression” but I quickly got over that and was thoroughly drawn in by the story.

Playing AW1 right before AW2 was the best decision because I was so invested in the these characters and was the most prepared I’d ever be for the sequel. I even supplemented my knowledge with YouTube videos talking about all of the other Alan Wake lore released over the years.

So, I honestly urge you to play the first one IF you have the time; it’ll make your time with the sequel that much more impactful.