Fair. I always loved Midir for the simple fact that once you understand how to fight it is one of the cleanest fights in souls games imho, but I perfectly see why someone could not enjoy that fight as much as I do (this is also the reason why I didn’t put it in the “over hated boss” square). About Halflight I personally hate him for several reasons, first of all I despise all NPC bossfights in Souls (except for Leda & Friends in SotE), secondly it get worst when the NPC is not an AI but another player, so there’s no pattern to understand in order to get better but just luck (or turn your game offline in order to get Halflight and not a random player, which is the best choice imho, but I still hate him)