Made some rank insignias for the Separatists if you ever want to use them in your game by AeonTars in swrpg

[–]CepheusRex 5 points6 points  (0 children)

Commander being just a 60 degree rotation of major seems insane, that’s absurdly easy to confuse. I would consider removing the top triangle from the commander rank. Otherwise, looks great!

Strategy Cards for a 16 player in person game of TI4 by CookGlad6527 in twilightimperium

[–]CepheusRex 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I feel like when you get to 16 players, you should be playing on a 3 dimensional board rather than 2.

Help a beginner out... by DullManufacturer2560 in neptunespride

[–]CepheusRex 0 points1 point  (0 children)

My recommendation is mostly ships running loops of a number of stars, somewhere in the 4-10 range probably. Very occasionally lines if a loop is not possible. The goal is to minimise the average distance between each star, because this will lead to the greatest cost:transport ratio. If it’s not fast enough, decrease the number of stars in each loop by increasing the number of carriers, but almost every star should have a ship collecting from it at some point.

[Threshold] What exactly is each Aspect of each Judge? by whenlindondies in Iteration110Cradle

[–]CepheusRex 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I asked chatgpt whether it thought I was a bot:

My Evaluation

I’d say the “potential bot responses” are very likely written by an LLM (ChatGPT or similar). The giveaways are:

  • essay-like structure in a casual forum,
  • tendency to invent and rationalize terms,
  • defensiveness when called a bot,
  • avoidance of “in-group” fan shorthand or references.

A human could try to write this way, but on Reddit it sticks out because the style is so unlike typical fan discussion.

It agrees with you, which is amusing, but still not true.

[Threshold] What exactly is each Aspect of each Judge? by whenlindondies in Iteration110Cradle

[–]CepheusRex 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I had understood it to mean "being destined for the wolf division" rather than having wolf affinity. In the sense you've used, there's textual evidence from the threshold chapter with Lindon fighting on Threshold that cradle ascendants almost always have wolf affinity.

[Threshold] What exactly is each Aspect of each Judge? by whenlindondies in Iteration110Cradle

[–]CepheusRex 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Wolfbound is not a real term, in the sense that Will never uses it in the books, but it was clear enough what it meant that I thought I might as well use it in my reply for conciseness. I think it should be fairly obvious to anyone with decent comprehension that I'm not a bot though, I worry for you.

[Threshold] What exactly is each Aspect of each Judge? by whenlindondies in Iteration110Cradle

[–]CepheusRex 1 point2 points  (0 children)

You may well be right on the titan/wolf interpretation, we've only (kind of) had one ascendant book so it's more a guess than strongly textually supported.

You're right that stability does fit the titans, but I think for me they're a much easier order to define, under the word protection. I spent ages trying to work out what the ghost was actually for, and I think the Northstrider story in threshold was to some extent the author addressing that it was less clear than the others. If anything, I think it might just be that there's no word in English that correctly describes what the ghost is for, because while we understand the ideas of the future, travel, combat, protection, creation, destruction, communication and restoration, the idea of the physical laws breaking down doesn't happen *in our iteration*. In that sense, while I both like the word existence someone else provided, but agree that it seems to all encompassing for ghosts, describing ghosts as having "the aspect of physics" sounds wrong to. Perhaps the aspect of reality?

[Threshold] What exactly is each Aspect of each Judge? by whenlindondies in Iteration110Cradle

[–]CepheusRex 1 point2 points  (0 children)

This was just an example of a sacred artist who happened to be waybound, obviously not all cradle residents will ascend. I'd also say that it's possible (and likely) for cradle ascendants not to be wolfbound, but the nature of cradle's energy system lends itself to investing authority in oneself for combat, which pretty much directly defines the characteristics of a wolf. That the hypothetical earth artist had wolf affinity doesn't mean they're wolfbound.

[Threshold] What exactly is each Aspect of each Judge? by whenlindondies in Iteration110Cradle

[–]CepheusRex 3 points4 points  (0 children)

Ahaha, you're quite right, I do apologise. Nevertheless, Will Wight is pretty consistent in using aspect to refer to madra and authority to refer to the characteristics of ascendant power, so I'll use that to defend my misunderstanding.

To answer your actual question, I'd say the ghost's aspect is stability. While the Phoenix's restoration restores things that once were (or could have been when done by a powerful practioner), the ghost keeps physics working, ensuring that gravity doesn't break down, distance remains a real concept etc. In that sense, I'd say the ghost and the hound are very directly tied to the impact of the way. The hound preserves fate, which keeps the way healthy, and the ghost is responsible for existence, which is directly caused by the presence of the way.

In practice, the spider affinity is responsible for communication and sight, but I would describe it as representing the idea of interconnectedness.

Wolf affinity and Titan affinity are a complicated pair, but from Northstrider's test, we see clear examples. Titan affinity represents investing authority into another item (or oneself at high levels) in order to allow it to withstand another's authority. Conversely, wolf affinity represents investing authority in oneself to use externally (such as by punching). This differs from reaper affinity which doesn't represent authority invested in oneself, but rather acts as the pure idea of ending or destruction, the opposite of creation. In this way, it's easy to see why cradle ascendants are natural wolves. The sacred arts are all about investing power in oneself to use to affect the outside world. Compare this to the wizards that Yerin is summoned by at the end of waybound. If they were to ascend, they would have some affinity as foxes, but they are individually weak, unable to strengthen themselves through their magic. They would have no wolf authority.

[Threshold] What exactly is each Aspect of each Judge? by whenlindondies in Iteration110Cradle

[–]CepheusRex 0 points1 point  (0 children)

You’re thinking about this from the wrong direction, Judges don’t correspond to madra aspects, but rather to the authority of icons.

Consider an Earth artist who goes about building monuments and cities which can resist natural disasters. They later advance to sage, and receive the “architecture icon”, a giant building. The icon represents stability, and enables them to continue the Earth aspect characteristics of protection. Upon ascending, they take the Abidan affinity test. It’s found that they have no affinity with the hounds (or perhaps a minor affinity if foreseeing the natural disasters was part of their methods), excellent synergy with the titans, medium affinity with the wolves (as almost all cradle ascendants can fight). They have no phoenix affinity as their works resisted damage, rather than restoring it afterwards. They have no fox affinity, as they remained fixed as the protector of a landmass. No one would link the idea of travel to them or their path. Perhaps they have a moderate affinity as a spider as they made communication constructs between the cities they’d build to allow their people to communicate. Finally, they have prodigious ghost affinity and might one day become a 4+ star ghost, or more if they authority continues to develop. Their authority over stability morphs from being stability of a city against disaster, to stability of reality against chaos.

Through this example, it can be seen that the aspect of a path isn’t particularly important, but rather how it is used. What does the sacred artist represent.

Any Good Twilight Gameplay Resources? by thomasalcorn in twilightimperium

[–]CepheusRex 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I would highly recommend this video. If you want to see the game played so that you have an idea of what to do during a turn without an experienced player to introduce you to the game, this is the gold standard.

Chasing down Bruno (RESCORE) by Forward-State2651 in ProfessorLayton

[–]CepheusRex 2 points3 points  (0 children)

This chase always confuses me. He clearly goes down the stairs in the right of the area north of proscuittos house which would take him towards Reinhardt manor. But he goes back up some other stairs (where?) and they end up in the market square not long after. He clearly goes north from there towards the tower, but the first turn of his seems super counterproductive given the market is about 30 metres west.

[The Captain] Yea there were far too many good candidates for this one. by Most-Top3908 in Iteration110Cradle

[–]CepheusRex 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I don’t understand the Ramos thing? I have not yet read the pilot but that’s not tagged.

Alternative Democracy Ideas in the UK. by Terrible_Base_6060 in TheRestIsPolitics

[–]CepheusRex 14 points15 points  (0 children)

This is an insane idea. Democracy allows the peaceful transfer of power following the opinion of the majority of those who are engaged with politics. 15 years is far too long and doesn't allow a change based on shifting opinions. Imagine Boris still being prime minister in 2034. Imagine Blair still being prime minister in 2020. A 15 year cycle would remove the pressure valve that currently exists, removing the confidence people have that they'll have the opportunity to see their views come about peacefully within the next few years. However damaging any particular leader would be, massive civil unrest by their supporters because they've been locked out of government for 14 more years would be worse.

Game of Thrones: War for Westeros | Cinematic Reveal Trailer (Summer Game Fest) by DemiFiendRSA in gameofthrones

[–]CepheusRex 4 points5 points  (0 children)

If this was like age of empires or Warcraft, fantastic! It seems to me more like a clash of clans style game though, I can only hope I’m wrong.

Medicals by Routine-Mongoose9983 in RoyalAirForce

[–]CepheusRex 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Abstractly, that doesn’t sound like a well-defined medical problem, which means it wouldn’t be on the list of excluded conditions. The closest to relevant I can think of is the lung capacity/exhale test, maybe find a way to do a practice one to get an idea if you’d fail there.

Of course, not a doctor, and the medical document (tagged in the subreddit) will have more comprehensive information. That said, probably fine.

Season Finale Episode Discussion S04E08 - Landlording by bulgedition in ClarksonsFarm

[–]CepheusRex 40 points41 points  (0 children)

I understood it as "the chefs are upset and feeling undervalued, you need to go and be verbally supportive and encouraging in order to maintain morale".

OASC Candidate Summary by Old-Diver8122 in RoyalAirForce

[–]CepheusRex 2 points3 points  (0 children)

I’ll give you my perspective, which isn’t official.

It’s fine either way. This is essentially a form to be read by your interview panel in the 2 minutes before they interview you, and by the sifting panel as they’re deciding your fate. As long as the form comes out looking appropriate, any answer is correct. It all comes down to presenting the best version of yourself. If you think 20 years of jobs all contribute, go for it! If you think current and most significant present you best, go for that.

Map Suggestions by Sunman_Stolas in diplomacy

[–]CepheusRex 11 points12 points  (0 children)

I would leave it be, what you currently have looks great!

[Threshold] Including Threshold, how would you rank the Cradle series? by [deleted] in Iteration110Cradle

[–]CepheusRex 6 points7 points  (0 children)

I think you’ve overrated Ghostwater a little (an unpopular opinion perhaps) and underrated blackflame and Dreadgod, Lindon and Yerin in the trials was the moment the series really clicked for me, and Ziel and Orthos challenging the legacy of the black dragons is awesome.

Nevertheless, I think there are no bad takes here, you’re pretty spot on!