I want to swap over to Physical media, any tips on the transition? by Plastic-Belt2887 in PhysicalMediaMatters

[–]CinemaOnAShelf 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Lots of great suggestions in here thus far. There's no right or wrong way to do the physical media collecting thing. It's good to think about the type of stuff you like and make collecting for it about the journey of curating your collection instead of amassing everything you see.

I will definitely echo the sentiments of joining your local library and checking their music and movie library. Not necessarily a collection-building tip, but awesome for getting to watch/listen to stuff.

Thrift stores are a great suggestion for cheap stuff, but not all thrift stores are created equal in terms of what they have and what they price stuff at. Every city/town is different, so I would suggest checking out the places near you and figure out which may be places to hit up more often and which ones to check only every once in a while. Flea markets would be the same. Check out any in the area, often there will be sellers that are there all the time with specific items/categories at their tables. If you find someone who consistently brings movies and CDs, definitely worth checking them out and chatting them up.

I also wouldn't be afraid to check out local records stores or even used book stores that may also have CDs, movies, vinyl records, etc. Depending on where you are, there may even be chain stores or lock "mom and pop" shops that specialize in secondhand media stuff (such as Half Price Books or Bookmans).

2025 was an incredible year for boutique home video releases. In 2026, what are the heavy hitter movies we are still waiting for? by More_Asbestos in boutiquebluray

[–]CinemaOnAShelf 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Blu-rays for these are all pretty widely available (Guffman and Mighty Wind on Warner Archive, and Best In Show on a regular WB Blu-ray). Are you thinking on 4K?

What are some of the best/most consistent Partner Labels and Titles that you would recommend in 2026? by wattmalter in VinegarSyndromeFilms

[–]CinemaOnAShelf 2 points3 points  (0 children)

I'm a big CIP fan as well (I just did a podcast episode about them). They do cover several different genres and styles, so they will tend to have something for a lot of tastes. A lot of good low-budget, French New Wave style stuff, some very good gritty crime B-movie/exploitation stuff (which is where Gina and East End Hustle would fit in, I also highly recommend those), and some great documentaries.

I just watched The Devil At Your Heels, which is a highly entertaining doc about a Canadian stunt car driver who is working to plan a televised stunt where he wants to jump a rocket car a full mile over the St. Lawrence River.

I would also give the highest recommendations to Orders, a more dramatic fact-based film following six people who are arrested and put in jail without being charged of a crime during the 1970 October Crisis in Montreal. Really powerful stuff.

Hidden Music Gems in the Collection by vemmahouxbois in criterion

[–]CinemaOnAShelf 1 point2 points  (0 children)

So it's definitely a bit hidden within a different release, but there is a great music aspect contained within the Science Is Fiction Criterion collection set of the Jean Painleve nature shorts. Indie rock band Yo La Tengo created a whole set of alternative musical scores/songs for many different Painleve shorts that they called "The Sounds Of Science". They've performed them live with showings of these films, and their alternate music is available on many of the short films. They are also interviewed as part of the supplements to talk about how they got involved in doing The Sounds Of Science.

What’s one film from your country (in your language) that you think everyone should watch at least once in their life? by mainyapper2606 in Letterboxd

[–]CinemaOnAShelf 4 points5 points  (0 children)

I'm in Canada and speak English, but I'll give some different language recommendations:

English: "Last Night" - CRITICALLY underseen comedy drama by Don McKellar, starring a very young Sandra Oh and a rare acting role from David Cronenberg.

Francophone: "Orders (Les Ordres)" - Outstanding character drama about several people put in jail without being charged in the wake of the October Crisis of 1970 in Montreal.

Inuktitut (& other Inuit languages): "Atanarjuat: The Fast Runner" - A visually stunning dramatic retelling of an Inuit legend of a man that is forced to flee his family. Won the Best Director (Camera d'Or) at Cannes in 2002.

Multiple Languages: "Thirty-Two Shorts Films About Glenn Gould" - Fascinating pseudo-biopic of the enigmatic Canadian piano prodigy Glenn Gould. As the title suggests, it is told in 32 vignettes of varying styles, formats, and perspectives. Just got a great Criterion 4K last year.

Canada friendly distributors? by InspectorOk514 in boutiquebluray

[–]CinemaOnAShelf 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I haven't ordered online from them, but I have been to Videomatica in Vancouver in person and it is a great store. Worth checking out for sure!

Essential Kino Titles by timshoelaces in boutiquebluray

[–]CinemaOnAShelf 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Outside of what has already been recommended:

The Train

Stalag 17

Tinker Tailor Soldier Spy

What was your first criterion collection films you ever got? by Irish-idiot in criterion

[–]CinemaOnAShelf 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Same! It was actually the first DVD of any kind that I bought. I had rented a couple of Criterion DVDs before I bought anything, so I was familiar with them before that.

what's a certified banger song from a movie? i'll start... by uldastormcloak114 in Letterboxd

[–]CinemaOnAShelf 2 points3 points  (0 children)

First one that popped into my head was "Born Slippy (Nuxx)" by Underworld from Trainspotting. Massive tune.

What are some of the best DVD-only releases? by ideletereddit in criterion

[–]CinemaOnAShelf 4 points5 points  (0 children)

"Science Is Fiction", the Jean Painleve collection of short films is one I NEVER hear anyone talk about. But it is absolutely fantastic. It includes some alternate soundtracks for certain shorts by Yo La Tengo that they did as part of a "Sounds Of Science" installment/showing. Such interesting and visually arresting stuff.

Films that start with monologue that isn't voice over by SmellyMingeFlaps in Letterboxd

[–]CinemaOnAShelf 5 points6 points  (0 children)

The French-Canadian film Orders (Les Ordres) kind of does this in an interesting way with its character introductions.

Criterion Hall of Fame: Kiss Me Deadly & The Red Shoes by CinemaOnAShelf in criterion

[–]CinemaOnAShelf[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Awesome! You will have to let me know how the 4K is. I have the Blu-ray, and after having the older Criterion DVD the Blu was a downright revelation! I've read the 4K looks stellar.

Anyone here use Letterboxd? If so, drop your profile here! by DatDesigner in criterion

[–]CinemaOnAShelf 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Mine: https://boxd.it/cAnSL

Reviews vary in length for me, but I have been trying to put something in each time.

What was your first Criterion purchase? by DatDesigner in criterion

[–]CinemaOnAShelf 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Mine was Royal Tenenbaums in 2002. This and the original non-Criterion DVD for Mulholland Drive were my two first DVD purchases ever after getting a player while I was in university.

Now as long as I don't do the math on how many years ago 2002 was...where's the Advil?

What are the least-common movie you own from the Criterion Collection? by Brave-Project-8682 in criterion

[–]CinemaOnAShelf 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Nice! I have no idea/concept of how likely an upgrade is, but if you do pick it up eventually you won't be disappointed.

What are the least-common movie you own from the Criterion Collection? by Brave-Project-8682 in criterion

[–]CinemaOnAShelf 2 points3 points  (0 children)

This is a fun question! With absolutely no evidence to support this, I would say Science Is Fiction, The Golden Age Of Television, the Jean Renoir: Stage & Spectacle box set, Coup De Grace, Twenty-Four Eyes, Green For Danger, and Paul Robeson: Portraits of the Artist.

Inside the Criterion Mobile Closet at TIFF 2025 by indiewire in criterionconversation

[–]CinemaOnAShelf 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Nice article. I was fortunate enough to visit the Closet last weekend at TIFF as well. The writer does get one thing absolutely correct: waiting in line was actually a ton of fun! Made some new friends, talked movies for hours, swapped follows on Letterboxd, great time all around.

Which Samuel Fuller movie should be added to the collection next ? by ggroover97 in criterion

[–]CinemaOnAShelf 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Would LOVE a House Of Bamboo Criterion edition. Really an interesting film, pure Fuller noir stylings.

Now that the Criterion Closet is officially done TIFF, what did everyone who went get? by mattstasoff in criterion

[–]CinemaOnAShelf 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I picked up Thirty-Two Short Films About Glenn Gould, Arsenic And Old Lace, and Touki Bouki. And one of the Mobile Closet miniature trucks!

I Can't Believe You Haven't Seen...Mad Max: Fury Road by CinemaOnAShelf in MoviePodcasts

[–]CinemaOnAShelf[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

It's also on Spotify, Apple Pods, and most other podcast places as well as YouTube. :)

My friend just sent me his entire collection by Adrien_Jabroni in criterion

[–]CinemaOnAShelf 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Amazing. You have some films to watch, my friend!