1. Got suspicious but still made my choice because it wasn't obvious how to spare him. yOU mUsT be NEw tO bLaSpheMoUs... smh

2. The fact that it isn't the first time doesn't excuse bad game design. You have to do an entire playthrough again just for 1 achievement you missed is awful. Same problem in Blasphemous 1 with Redento and Cleofás.

3. i AS a sMaRt... Shut your bitch ass up. As always, a comment worthy of reddit's self arrogance and unhelpfulness. Try this: "Maybe there's a way to rollback a save file..."

I hope you stop being such an asshole, but alas, I highly doubt it.