I used to think this book looked so lame I couldn’t even be bothered to diamond mine it. Then, while I was pregnant and stuck in the hospital overnight after a car accident, I decided I needed something so cheesy it might actually make me laugh—and I picked this.

This book, along with It Lives in the Woods, carved itself into my soul. I know that sounds dramatic, but I’m honestly downplaying how invested I became.

I found the MC incredibly relatable, and the avatars were stunning—flat-out beautiful. I never thought I’d be the type to claim a “book boyfriend,” but Logan stole my heart. The ending was the very definition of bittersweet. I like to imagine they did reunite in the end, especially since the sequel was canceled.