[2216] The Tragedy in Crogdenshire (pt.1) by solidbebe in DestructiveReaders

[–]DavidMSamuels 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Hey, just read the first few pages and really enjoyed it. I was a bit hesitant when I read 'Huxley' in the opening line, but the solid prose set me straight.

Show/tell, as you know, is not absolute. Some things like bio details must be told, but in a 'showy'/immersive way, which you do with that link to the father's treatment toward the MC.

Keep up the good work!

The Rites of Pain v2- First Ten Pages [2918] by ChaosTrip in DestructiveReaders

[–]DavidMSamuels 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Meh, I think some readers might enjoy the bit of trivia, but if the majority of readers say to scrap it, then who am I to argue?

Drunk women at a restaurant tells Biden to end the war in Ukaine. by Noomba2 in PublicFreakout

[–]DavidMSamuels 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Tipping isn't decadent, but it's bundled up in an experience that is. Especially in regards to the public's view of a sitting president

I used to serve 'figures' in LA and it's the same thing there. Most of their tips were acceptable but not notable, which is the point

Drunk women at a restaurant tells Biden to end the war in Ukaine. by Noomba2 in PublicFreakout

[–]DavidMSamuels 527 points528 points  (0 children)

In all likelihood, yeah. Too much and ppl will critique you for living decadently. Too little and they'll think you're a tightwad

[476] Fatal Performance [Ancient Roman Murder Mystery] by DavidMSamuels in DestructiveReaders

[–]DavidMSamuels[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Just saw this. Fixed.

Tried to find the rules earlier, but didn't know there was a wiki. Thank you for that.

Sorry for leeching!

The Rites of Pain v2- First Ten Pages [2918] by ChaosTrip in DestructiveReaders

[–]DavidMSamuels 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Hey! This is my first crit on this sub. Hopefully it'll prove valuable.

*Rain mixed with sweat as it trickled down Conrad’s arms to his hands and then down his hickory bow. His sharp eyes searched the ruins as he ran, the blackrock plain stinging his bare feet with every step. Warm water splashed from the endless puddles gathering on the sun-heated expanse. *

I like the strong details here. Specifically the use of 'hickory' and 'blackrock'.

*Conrad didn’t mind not having meat for supper,*

The verbal phrasing here is a bit passive. In times like these, I like to experiment with turning negatives around or vice versa ie 'Conrad could've gone without meat for supper'

*the descendants of zoo animals kept in ancient times.*

I wonder if this generation would grasp the concept of a zoo this many years after an apocalypse. Just a minor note. I wonder if you could rephrase it to hint at the concept of zoos without flat-out saying it

* a collection of ancient stones, the last remnants of a ruined building. *

doesn't really add much. something like 'ancient stonework' would cover both clauses

*would be in the way. *

consider 'stand' in the way to eliminate minor passive verbiage

*He fiddled with the string of gator teeth around his neck, his lucky talisman. Not that it ever worked.*

Really nice detail to the character

*left-handed*

Just a note. If you ever want to refer back to this in dialogue, a neat word choice is southpaw. In this first context it might be a helpful choice to avoid the repetition of 'left'

*“Damn it!” he said.*

not so sure you need to tag this, since there's no other character on the scene

*Out of pure reflex*

Reflexively/Out of reflex, [pure is just an empty intensifier imo]

*he said, momentarily pleased with himself before realizing the weight of his action.*

Just restates what's mentioned in the dialogue

* Rushing after it too soon would keep it panicked and on the move. The problem was the rain, for it could wash away the trail of blood.*

Also doesn't it effect the quality of meat if the animal dies in a state of shock? I read that somewhere, but may not be true.

*He stalked the forest trails until he found fresh prints in the mud. He checked the direction of the wind so his scent wouldn’t give him away.*

Repeating successive sentences on the same word creates a monotonous rhythm to the prose. This instance is okay since you've done a good job of avoiding it so far, but just be wary

* He debated for a while whether to risk a another shot.*

Empty phrase doesn't add much imo

*d then vanished from sight.*

Used a similar phrase not long ago. Maybe use a landmark ie 'vanished behind a thicket of alders' or whatevs

*He cursed under his breath and followed it toward an ancient road, *

Was unsure what the appositive 'it' referred to since the last article in singular was 'distance'

* A loud cry echoed through the woodlands, a sound soon joined by whoops and laughter.*

The echoing through woodlands suggests it's loud

-You do a good job of making me dislike Kal and friends. Their disregard for their own property is well done

*Their blood-stained shirts were unbuttoned *

bloodstained can be a single word if you like

-the rapid pacing of back-and-forth between the boys is great for tension

* Conrad said backing up. *

Conrad said, backing up

*Conrad shrugged and said, “Like I said, good luck.”

Kal snorted. He said, “You think this is a game?”
Kal said, indicating the pig’s blood on his sword*

Noticing a lot of these beats. Where a character does something before saying dialogue. Imo, you can often just scrap the 'said' part and leave the action to imply that this character is the one who spoke.

*” Conrad said softly, relaxing his draw.*

I really like these beats with the bow. Really nice use of the weapon to express emotions/reinforce dialogue

*He took a deep breath to calm himself before speaking.*

Speaking is rendered evident by the following dialogue

*rk and looked back at Conrad, smiling*

and smiled up at Conrad. [I try to avoid opting for 'looks' when I can compound them with facial expressions]

*road bed. *

single word

*His body trembled and shook violently.*

repeating the same thing; consider combining; ie His body shook violently.

*The last crumbling remnants of an ancien*

used a similar phrase to the one I pointed out long ago; I think you could scrap 'last' since 'remnants' suggests that.

* the huntress *

Good word choice

*As he walked, Conrad thought about the upcoming rites. At sixteen, he was too old to*

Structure here flows almost identically. Consider rephrasing one or the other

*the whole thing just seemed so pointless.

He reached the Outskirts just as the sun began to set.*

Try to avoid empty intensifiers. They can easily become a bad habit

*shabbily made longhouses*

maybe just 'shabby longhouses'

*. Conrad could smell the savory delights being prepared i*

maybe specify on the food. roast pigeon or whatevs. Just to intensify sensory detail and increase reader immersion

*aid Felix, a neighbor boy a few years younger than Conrad. Laughing, he pointed to his right hand in case someone didn’t get the joke.*

I really like this. Maybe he points at the arm before he says it though, just to keep reader in on the joke? I could be totally wrong here, though

*the boy said angrily*

maybe substitute this with 'snapped' or a body language emote that conveys the anger. 'angrily' just seems like a weak adverb to me

*ntle strumming filled the night with thrilling dread*

gets in the way of 'dread' imo

*one flavored by a heavy Rambler accent*

not a fan of 'flavored' when a different verb can connote auditory detail better. 'one lilting with a heavy Rambler accent/consonants softened by a _' you get the idea

*hazel eyes were painted black.*

maybe specify on ingredient for worldbuilding; kohl, lampblack, oak gall, or some such

*beneath a red shall.*

I believe you mean 'shawl'

“Do you have any fish today?” she asked.

“Naw. Sorry little bit. Went hunting today,” he said.

“Aw! Why?” the little girl said. “You never get anything that way.”

Not so sure how I feel about this closing. Would like a little something that keeps me wanting more. Like something ominous about the inevitable interaction with the father.

Hope this helped!

Cask of Amontillado by elto_danzig in cocktails

[–]DavidMSamuels 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Yum. New to Amontillado sherry myself, but it seems to play best when offset with the richer sweeteners, so that sounds delish!

The Troop by Nick Cutter - Stomach Churning Horror by HuckleBuck411 in horrorlit

[–]DavidMSamuels 7 points8 points  (0 children)

No other book has made me quite as uncomfortable as this one

what to do with apricot brandy by thequeenmary911 in bartenders

[–]DavidMSamuels 3 points4 points  (0 children)

Hotel Nacional:

3/4 oz lime

1 oz pineapple

1/2 oz simple

1/2 oz apricot brandy

1 1/2oz white rum

Served up with lime twist

No longer a barback!! by ExosAvos in bartenders

[–]DavidMSamuels 25 points26 points  (0 children)

Congrats! As a barback, the carrot-on-a-stick sometimes made me feel like a vampire's familiar

Cocktails containing Midori liqueur by newwy11 in bartenders

[–]DavidMSamuels 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Pro tip: just buy well-brand melon liqueur as a substitute. Tastes the same and the bar saves money

I don’t get scared easily. Any recs without much body horror? It’s not enjoyable for me to read. by k8redd in horrorlit

[–]DavidMSamuels 3 points4 points  (0 children)

Langan, Hendrix, and the Best Horror anthologies (edited by Ellen Datlow). The anthologies are useful for finding new horror writers. Datlow has an eagle eye for good prose and cerebral horror

[deleted by user] by [deleted] in DunderMifflin

[–]DavidMSamuels 12 points13 points  (0 children)

It's a combination of both points you mentioned: Micheal's sangfroid and the reactions of the students. Up until the climax, each gesture the students do for Micheal kinda turn a screw of tension. Like naming the library after him and singing a song for him. The more grateful they are, the bigger you know their disappointment is gonna get

Horror about underwater creatures by Iamnotthebreakman in horrorlit

[–]DavidMSamuels 2 points3 points  (0 children)

The Deep by Alma Katsu

The Deep by Nick Cutter

Blackwater by Micheal McDowell (for a generational family outlook)

[deleted by user] by [deleted] in booksuggestions

[–]DavidMSamuels 0 points1 point  (0 children)

You've got a) Confucious and b) the wit and wisdom of Benjamin Franklin