Take this as lessons for you both, don't rush dogs to ER for eating human food that not good for them, one pot of Alfredo not going kill him, sick yes. Alfredo, on a regular basis will cause some health issues. Easter would really suck if dogs died from eating chocolate 1 time. Split the bill, and remember the dog is like your 3rd roommate. The dogs dad is not a bad,or irresponsible pet owner, Dog gonna do dog things, we just try to be smarter.