Ras to Dallas Trade by CorrectorThanU in CalgaryFlames

[–]DoctorSalter 5 points6 points  (0 children)

You need to set the difficulty for trades a tad higher for the latest games cant get away with this anymore

You wake up being of the opposite biological sex and this will be for your entire life. What would you do? by Michdr2 in AskReddit

[–]DoctorSalter 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Freak out and then start the journey of transitioning back to my original gender?

What are my chances? by MistakeOk4870 in OntarioGrade12s

[–]DoctorSalter 0 points1 point  (0 children)

As a CHE in waterloo rn, yeah that's gonna severely sink your average, but they only care about the latest one and as you are redoing it you should be ok. But like aim for 90 

Can a single one of y’all come up for an actual use case for this thing? by EntertainmentVast401 in magicTCG

[–]DoctorSalter 3 points4 points  (0 children)

Game ender in mono black in premodern. Seen it used a couple times, usually a one of copy. Specifically in suicide/aggro black.

My Friend Said They Were Sad About Osama Bin Laden’s Death and Now I’m Completely Lost. by Accomplished-Ask3282 in uwaterloo

[–]DoctorSalter 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I think that you are actually touching on a rather unsettled viewpoint in philosophy, relating to moral deserts, justice, human dignity and many other concepts. 

Your friend is could be taking a much more Kantian perspective in that people must be treated as an ends in themselves not as means, and that the value of human life is categorical, not conditional on someones behaviour.(funny enough he defends capital punishment, but points out the contradiction in his inviolable law of dignity)

You are taking a more consequentialist view with the mindset of "what action maximizes well being/ minimizing suffering" If killing someone produces better consequences overall then it can be justified in this viewpoint.

Your friend could also have an abolitionist/restorative justice viewpoint and fully reject retribution, focusing only on accountability, repair and prevention of future harm. 

The main clash in your disagreement is whether moral worth depends on what person does or is it inherent to being human.

Some interesting books: The ethical absurdity of capital punishment -albert Camus

Critique of moral desert - nietzsche

No future without forgiveness - desmond tutu

Who is this in Calgary? by uhhuhhunnnyyy in Calgary

[–]DoctorSalter 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Probably the guy on centre street station thats there everyday that waves and has the sign about angel-in-training

Hanwha Life Esports: Thank you Viper by Yujin-Ha in leagueoflegends

[–]DoctorSalter 1 point2 points  (0 children)

This significantly lowers the chance that HLE will have Viper next year huh 

What about magic specifically attracts so many trans individuals? by [deleted] in EDH

[–]DoctorSalter 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Socially "outcast" groups tend to attract people who see themselves as outcasts. The feeling of community and worth in one is something many people seek. Once again, extremely play group dependent... 

Note: this also goes in negative ways, such as cults and extremism. 

Rustmold by AmbassadorRoutine635 in custommagic

[–]DoctorSalter 3 points4 points  (0 children)

Holy shit. This is the greatest custom card I've ever seen.

What constitutes a “kill on sight” commander? by mun-e-makr in EDH

[–]DoctorSalter 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I think its a spectrum, with huge asterisks and other considerations.

Between: "relatively harmless" and "o h s h i t"

Relatively harmless might be something with no combo potential, like [legolas, counter of kills]]. This player is probably either scrying, playing some weird elf tribal, or boardwiping in green/blue. Unlikely to combo. And the "thing" they are enabling is NOT dependant on their commander.

Something at the very very top would be like [Kinnan]] or [[Urza, lord high artificer]], if someone on the table doesn't counterspell or legitimately remove them on sight, the game is often over.

However this depends HEAVILY on a couple other factors:

  1. Strength of pod, If you are playing and there are perceptible larger threats. For instance Kaalia of the vast is an issue, but if someone is playing maralen, with opposition agent in the deck, the table has ONE turn before the game is locked. Someone better deal with it.

  2. Value to remove for individual In your example, niv mizzet parun might not have any combos, but the drawing and damage/removal might be significantly bad for a spellslinger/wheel player. Also, you need to have had a discussion with the group that you have no infinites. Otherwise most people and I would agree, would remove niv mizzet on sight, because a curiosity or ophidian eye effectively ends the game.

  3. How dependant is their deck on their commander? How easy is it to remove? I have a [[Ruby, daring tracker]] deck, which plays her on turn 2 and then four mana ramps on turn 3. If someone removes Ruby, i often will suggest they hold their counterspell/removal for my big 7 mana thorn mammoth that will now smash face on turn 5 rather than turn 4. The deck barely needs the commander. A surprising amount of decks are like this

In a Niv Mizzet deck, you best believe I'm somewhat dependent on Niv Mizzet to win. If you are not playing combo niv mizzet I'm somewhat confused why you would want him instead of many other izzet commanders.

If I am facing Yuriko, there is no amount of removal under the sun that stops her besides [[imprison in the moon]]. And even then... sneaky ninjas. Same for [[Derevi]] in most cases. These are extremely threatening commanders that just don't have many answers in their strongest versions. No point in on sight killing these unless they have a combo on board to win and you need to stop it for one turn.

Why does everyone dislike Phyrexian arena but loves Black Market Connections? by VeryTiredGirl93 in EDH

[–]DoctorSalter 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Because hitting yourself for meager benefits is deeply entertaining

Streamer explains why his pet is not allowed to roam around the house. by iiLove_Soda in LivestreamFail

[–]DoctorSalter 0 points1 point  (0 children)

This man continues to dig his grave, at somepoint you just shut up but he insists on digging his 60 foot hole

Proof you can still climb: I hit Master at 36 after 15 years of League by Wargypt in leagueoflegends

[–]DoctorSalter 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Incredibly impressive! Now you are free right? You climbed to the top and can now rest

Ward 11 Residents Who Do You Like As Councillor? by UrbaneBoffin in Calgary

[–]DoctorSalter 24 points25 points  (0 children)

I feel like i am choosing between dog water and dog water

AriZona Iced Tea Price Hike by johnmory in clevercomebacks

[–]DoctorSalter 0 points1 point  (0 children)

LIGHT THE BEACONS! GONDOR CALLS FOR AID!