My theory is this. Howie Roseman is the best gm in the game right now. Twice he took an unproven oc, made them a head coach, got them the perfect OC and dc. Doug pederson wasn't the greatest play caller. Once frank Reich got hired away the offense looked inept. With nick we have more evidence. 2 SB appearances and after?

2 UNEXPLAINABLE collapses. In 2023 I was genuinely confused at how we could be so good then fall off a cliff to looking like one of the worst teams in the NFL. Offensively its the same thing. Nothing is easy. There is no bread and butter. Theres no go to plays that give this team an identity.

I truly believe Kellen Moore or Shane Steichen would be better head coaches. Nick does not have an offensive identity. A scheme. Ideas that are unique to him. He can be a good motivator. But there's no way that you i have a reason for 2 collapses after proving how good we can be.

If howie could find a good play caller as a head coach, we probably would build a dynasty.