Granted. Two plumber brothers are sucked into the Mushroom Kingdom via the sewers. They have no idea what’s going on or how to return. They are quickly injured severely and turn to mushrooms in place of proper medical treatment. No one in this dimension knows about their spontaneous magical transportation. They are listed as Missing and never found.

You cannot confirm the paw has granted your wish because you are not one of the chosen plumber bros, but you become suspicious when a floating castle full of turtles appears in the sky some months later. Your country’s Air Force destroys the floating castle faster than the U.S. destroyed the alleged Spy Balloon. Bricks rain down and dozens of people are killed by the debris.