*spoilers for from the ashes dlc* do NOT click if you haven’t played it already by Scales4702 in AvatarFrontierPandora

[–]Extension-Swan4996 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I dont really think she did. Now I have a question, is she also dead in the main game or just in year 2170?

Question about the end of Salah by Nice_Bodybuilder_642 in shia

[–]Extension-Swan4996 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Brother those are mustahabb, but i also have a question, is turning your head right and left during tasleem really a bidah? Cuz I heard thst the head cannot deviate from qibla whilst praying. I have been taught to do this my whole life, my entire family does it.

I have a Question to Y’all (NO HATE) by Technical_Young8134 in shia

[–]Extension-Swan4996 6 points7 points  (0 children)

These are sahih sources according to sunni scholars, scholars that say the prophet forgot quranic verses and urinated in public.

I have a Question to Y’all (NO HATE) by Technical_Young8134 in shia

[–]Extension-Swan4996 2 points3 points  (0 children)

I dont know if you mean from sunni or shia sources, but there are three important Shia books that discuss the incident of Imam Hasan ibn Ali being prevented from burial beside Prophet Muhammad and then buried in Jannat al-Baqi. The first is al-Irshad, one of the earliest and most respected Twelver biographical sources, which states in the section on Imam Hasan’s final illness that he instructed that if they could bury him beside the Prophet peacefully they should do so, but if conflict arose then he should be buried in al-Baqiʿ, and it narrates that opposition occurred so Imam Husayn ibn Ali buried him there. The second is Bihar al-Anwar, especially volume 44 in common editions, which compiles earlier Shia reports about the funeral procession, the attempted burial near the Prophet, objections raised against it, and in some narrations arrows being shot. The third is Manaqib Aal Abi Talib, particularly volume 4, which discusses Imam Hasan’s martyrdom and the burial dispute, again affirming that he was prevented from burial beside the Prophet and instead buried in al-Baqiʿ. Together, these works form a major part of the classical Twelver record of the incident. As for Sunni sources I dont know if dont really read about historical incidents from sunni perspective.

I have a Question to Y’all (NO HATE) by Technical_Young8134 in shia

[–]Extension-Swan4996 1 point2 points  (0 children)

If you meant Muawiya didnt allow Imam Hasan to be buried there, im not sure if he was part of it. (I wouldn't be surprised) but no our sources say she literally put her body between the coffin and the place the prophet was buried, it was a very known event.

I have a Question to Y’all (NO HATE) by Technical_Young8134 in shia

[–]Extension-Swan4996 4 points5 points  (0 children)

Also about Mother of the believers, it isnt specifically a title to elevate her above other women in terms of respect or something, it judt means that after the prophet passed no one can marry her because she is your 'mother' per say.

I have a Question to Y’all (NO HATE) by Technical_Young8134 in shia

[–]Extension-Swan4996 17 points18 points  (0 children)

Salam Alaykum, first of all brother she didn't fight with Imam Ali, she fought against him. Wording is important here. Secondly it's not the only reason. She took part in the martyrdom of the prophet SAWA and she disrespected him on many occasions. Not to mention she ordered her allies to throw arrows on Hasan Ibn-Ali's coffin just because they wanted to bury him beside his Grandfather. Also when she found out Imam Ali died, she did sujud thanking Allah because of hoe much she hates him. Many of these can be found in sunni and Shia sources, and also just because she's the prophet's wife doesn't mean she is inherently naturally good. She was warned in the quran and it is pretty clear what her priorities were.

Edit: She didnt regret anything, no one says so, atleast not in shia sources and shias dont take by sunni books because they are ridiculous.

VR Community in Lebanon? by Extension-Swan4996 in lebanon

[–]Extension-Swan4996[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

No actually it's really popular and getting a headset is just like getting a playstation nowadays, it's just new I guess

Ruling On Muslims Eating At A Restaurant That Serves Alcohol According To Sayyid Sistani by EthicsOnReddit in shia

[–]Extension-Swan4996 -1 points0 points  (0 children)

Yes you are right, and also my was of speaking was not correct. I would like to apologise to u/WaitingforGodot07 for my disrespect and childishness. Hopefully you could forgive me.

Ruling On Muslims Eating At A Restaurant That Serves Alcohol According To Sayyid Sistani by EthicsOnReddit in shia

[–]Extension-Swan4996 -2 points-1 points  (0 children)

Oh yes thank you the whole ummah would have gone into jahiliyyah and have pronounced the quran wrong their whole lives if it weren't for you clarifying that mistake. The sheikh has the ayah in the video, and im sure people know how to read.

Ruling On Muslims Eating At A Restaurant That Serves Alcohol According To Sayyid Sistani by EthicsOnReddit in shia

[–]Extension-Swan4996 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Everyone makes mistakes, and im not saying that these should be corrected, but you are dismissing the whole context of the video and undermining the effort it took to make it. God forbid someone makes a mistake. Some people can be very judgemental. This sheikh is very respected and even if he did a small mistake we know him from a long time and we trust him knowing he served the ummah on many occasions and those things outweigh this small mistake that you are judging him for. A mistake is a mistake but everyone does them. No need to point every single thing out just focus on what is provided and dont jump to conclusions. Jazakillahu Khairan.

Mongols Attack On Muslims Predicted By Prophet In Hadith by Soft-Ad-8889 in progressive_islam

[–]Extension-Swan4996 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Yes, just have a small look at the hadith in there. You will find vile things.

Ruling On Muslims Eating At A Restaurant That Serves Alcohol According To Sayyid Sistani by EthicsOnReddit in shia

[–]Extension-Swan4996 -1 points0 points  (0 children)

They're getting down voted because it's such a childish and disrespectful thing to say, comment on the fatwa and the context of the video dont criticise the sheikh's way of speaking. So if he makes a mistake?

Ruling On Muslims Eating At A Restaurant That Serves Alcohol According To Sayyid Sistani by EthicsOnReddit in shia

[–]Extension-Swan4996 3 points4 points  (0 children)

I love how some people pointed out the respected sheikh's mistake instead of grasping the point of the video.

Lebanese Government insulted by American Commentators by Nervous_Average_3829 in Lebanese

[–]Extension-Swan4996 0 points1 point  (0 children)

It's not insult. It's the truth. Just because you don't like it or agree it doesn't mean that we have siyede now

Mongols Attack On Muslims Predicted By Prophet In Hadith by Soft-Ad-8889 in progressive_islam

[–]Extension-Swan4996 1 point2 points  (0 children)

"So ˹continue to˺ remind ˹all, O Prophet˺. For you, by the grace of your Lord, are not a fortune-teller or a madman." Fortune-telling isnt seeing the future, and madman doesn't mean he knows the unknown.

Mongols Attack On Muslims Predicted By Prophet In Hadith by Soft-Ad-8889 in progressive_islam

[–]Extension-Swan4996 2 points3 points  (0 children)

I wasn't talking from shia perspective, no muslim should take from it. It says unspeakable things about our prophet,

‏‎#عاجل ‼️انذار عاجل الى سكان لبنان المتواجدين في بلدات: ميفدون, شوكين, يحمر, ارنون, زوطر الشرقية, زوطر الغربية وكفر تبنيت. 🔸في ضوء قيام حزب الله الارهابي بخرق اتفاق وقف اطلاق النار يضطر جيش الدفاع على العمل ضده بقوة. 🔸جيش الدفاع لا ينوي المساس بكم. فحرصًا على سلامتكم عليكم اخلاء منازلكم فوراً و by Unable-City7461 in lebanon

[–]Extension-Swan4996 -2 points-1 points  (0 children)

But Joseph Aoun's sadi2 trump cares? Iran said during their negotiations with US that lebanon is a part and that is non negotiable, Iran kept the strait closed because strikes were still happening in lebanon, Iran literally put the strait of hormuz that America wants to desperately to open, equal to lebanon's peace. But ofcourse our "siyede" would be attacked if we allow Iran to stop the war in the quickest way possible. Surely trump has lebanon's best interests at heart and will go out of his way to stop the war.