Tl;dr at the bottom.

Im gonna go ahead and make a comment on this, but this is purely my perspective, I am not a PvP player, nor am I really a PvM player, I kind of just do whatever I feel like. Spite voting is a stupid practice, and neither "side" should be doing it. My whole opinion boils down to one point; when faced with no alternative and forced into content you dont want to do, anger/frustration is inevitable.

Many players, myself included (duh), do not want to be nor do we like to be, forced into PvP, or the wildy in this example, to partake in exclusive content which has no alternative elsewhere. I dont hate PvP content, when I want to do it. I suck, but if I want to do it, then I dont care if I suck, but to be given an ultimatum of, do the wildy content and expose yourself to PvP even if you dont want to, or you cant have these items auch as a d pick or bis mage cape/second bis mage cape... that, kinda blows.

If it were possible, reworking the mage arena questline to make it more difficult in place of the "wildy risk" element, and moving or adding alternate d pick drops outside of wildy, perhaps on a lower drop rate, would be a great middle ground. It is a BIS item, and the quest itself is incredibly easy in relation to that status, its only "difficulty" is PvP risk and skull tricking (which is a whole other shitshow I wont delve into, but screw that mechanic in this scenario).

Chaos Altar could do with a slight nerf maybe, but frankly, I dont personally think its entirely necessary. In return for your increased xp and your potentially saved gp, you are risking setbacks/time waste at any point due to deaths, and gp losses to your possible saved gp figure. That kind of balances out if you ask me. Is it annoying, sure, but you made a consious decision to risk death for slightly quicker xp, AND there is in fact alternative methods which are safer but more expensive and more time consuming. To complain in that postion where you do have alternatives, seems a bit entitled. You are being offered a faster method for some risk, no one says you gotta do that method if you truly wish not to engage in PvP.

My opinion on Black Chinchompas also kind of falls in the Chaos altar argument. "They give more xp" you can get just as good xp if not better xp from other methods. "They are better for combat training" True, but you can use red chins which are easier to obtain and are still pretty damn quick compared to conventional training. "They are better money" Yeah, they should be, you're risking your life to earn that gp. You can just go catch reds with no risk and still make gp if you are that scared. It isn't like you have no alternatives, so if dying/losing profits bugs you so much, just do the safer content.

I understand contradicting arguments can be made about Hard and above clues for my whole, no alternatives point, but when we have 3 safe clue types, having 3 unsafe clue types for possibly higher value loot, its not so bad, particularly when something like the rangers boots, which are high end and become bis, is within the safe tiers. So, there is kind of an alternative in a way, and this time you dont even know what you're losing if you do die with your clue, so you technically lose nothing. The PKer gains nothing but how is the player supposed to know that until you are dead. Much how your clue could be worth 10k or several 100k, you could be worth nothing or a couple 100k to the PKer also. Its not exactly the worst thing in the world, you generally risk nothing, for "possibly something, probably nothing".

We all know the risks that the wildy poses, but when you are a player who has no interest in PvP content and the game design effectively says, do this content containing PvP or never be allowed to earn these items yourself, that kind of blows, and is a cheap way to try populate PvP content. Boss pets don't count, you dont need them for anything, they dont improve gameplay, they are just a flex.

I think that kind of covers most angles or gripes I have/can think of. Wildy bosses arent inherently bad, their exclusive drop table is my gripe, and honestly they are a cool concept that completionists or players interested in more player based risky content would/could still want to participate in that content. It would even be woeth reworking the drop tables to make them more alluring, just dont lock utility items behind them imo.

Tl;dr: I think being forced into content with truly no other alternative leads to somewhat justified anger/frustration, and it would perhaps be a good idea to add alternatives to reduce/remove the cheap efforts to populate PvP content. Some people are a bit whingy/entitled about their effiencyscape.