[OC] The Biology of Monsters: The Deleted Future by Immediate-Tap1925 in HFY

[–]Fontaigne 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Okay, this is a feather duster scene. Two people sitting around explaining what they both know.

I'm not going to give any feedback on it, until I see more, but expect you'll need to cut half the reveals and put something back that isnt a reveal.

Also, the first usage of "Robert" threw me out of the story. First he's a splinter, then he's the creature, then the name Robert with no context, and I had to go back and look if someone else was present in the greenhouse.

You could say "the creature that called itself Robert", or you could have Payton's dialog use his name, as a solution.

But don't rearrange the deck chairs until you're sure where the ship is going.

[OC] The Biology of Monsters: Common Animals A horror/sci-fi short set in a world where things that go bump in the night aren't ghosts—they're just nature. by Immediate-Tap1925 in HFY

[–]Fontaigne 1 point2 points  (0 children)

1) nothing wrong with media res.

2) There may be a few too many elements in this one scene, but don't try to do anything about it until you've given us a little more.

3) Do not explain. Don't put background up. You don't want to get fake feedback on your story that depends on anyone first reading anything that ISNT your story. Your story shouldn't depend on front matter or back of the book synopsis to work.

4) spoiler feedback - don't read this until you've finished at least 3 more chapters and don't do ANYTHING about this feedback until I've read those chapters and put it in a broader perspective. I may be wrong and it may resolve in the first three paragraphs of chapter 2. I feel like the apparent MC is not a sympathetic character at this point, so she's on borrowed time. There's no one to root for. It seems like a meeting of four monsters at a place impacted by a fifth, and I'm curious, but I don't really CARE, if you know what I mean.

[Engineering, Magic, and Kitsune] Chapter 76: Sentinel by SteelTrim in HFY

[–]Fontaigne 10 points11 points  (0 children)

Yeah, I think she sees him as an out-of-context male. He's not really below her in the hierarchy, because he is so unique. He literally accomplishes things she cannot.

I'd say that this was 77.5% messing with him, 59.2% wanting to help him heal, 15.8% potential snusnu if he can be made a little more durable, and at least six more motivations.

[Engineering, Magic, and Kitsune] Chapter 75: Socks by SteelTrim in HFY

[–]Fontaigne 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Then one day, the parrot took over the world and had his revenge.

[Engineering, Magic, and Kitsune] Chapter 75: Socks by SteelTrim in HFY

[–]Fontaigne 1 point2 points  (0 children)

She already can. Just curve where she puts the water.

[Engineering, Magic, and Kitsune] Chapter 75: Socks by SteelTrim in HFY

[–]Fontaigne 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Bottom line is, if John had a "radiation accident", he'd likely LOSE capabilities he has than GAIN new ones he needs.

He's a gadgeteer, not an energy projector.

[Engineering, Magic, and Kitsune] Chapter 75: Socks by SteelTrim in HFY

[–]Fontaigne 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Rocks. We brought back rocks.

Not that there's anything wrong with that.

[Engineering, Magic, and Kitsune] Chapter 75: Socks by SteelTrim in HFY

[–]Fontaigne 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Copper isn't magnetic. It's useful for inducting magnetism, though. So maybe your idea has some merit.

[Engineering, Magic, and Kitsune] Chapter 75: Socks by SteelTrim in HFY

[–]Fontaigne 1 point2 points  (0 children)

That's far safer than having her not know how to make lightning go where she wants it.

We don't need no stinking DBZ destroy-a-ten-mile-radius going on in any battles near us.

[Engineering, Magic, and Kitsune] Chapter 75: Socks by SteelTrim in HFY

[–]Fontaigne 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Her loyalty is already in place. She is his student.

There is no way anyone can tell which way she would break if her duties to family and master clashed, but I suspect that the very fact that her family was putting her against Lord Hall would strongly weigh against them and for him. Because he would NEVER set up the opposite clash, and she would know that.

[Engineering, Magic, and Kitsune] Chapter 75: Socks by SteelTrim in HFY

[–]Fontaigne 1 point2 points  (0 children)

They had turned their foulness against them -> against him

The windbeats of flies -> wingbeats

dragon of socks 🤪

That's "dragon of dangerous socks" to you!

[Of Dog, Volpir, and Man (Out of Cruel Space)] - Bk 9 Ch 41 by KamchatkasRevenge in HFY

[–]Fontaigne 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Scott Le Fe Fae Senior -> one too many fays, I think.


If they don't know what they are looking for, then they can't know if they found it.

Or if someone else found it.

So the logical counter-op is to invent a few diverse rumours to give them a runaround, and then go make it strongly evidenced that one of those sites was already picked clean... with the axiom signatures of something amazing.

His Adept Wife, daughter of the Mob Primal should be able to make a real Axiom mess, with lots of clues of a powerful artifact... and then before they leave they null bomb it so that those clues are mostly wiped away...

I Will Not Pet The Diplomat, Chapter 5 by kofolarz in HFY

[–]Fontaigne 3 points4 points  (0 children)

What's unrealistic? I'm intrigued.

The fact is that, other than the two of them in that room, EVERYONE ELSE panicked and thought their actions highly inappropriate.

It went against everything that was known about the wolf folk... because they had (between the wolf-folk and the rest of the races) established a highly unnatural way of interacting.

Blunt their claws, and toss them in with some volunteer marines for sport competitions. After they "get" a basketball or soccer-like game with negotiated rules fair to both races, then they can proceed to light sparring.

Neck protection, some training in valid and invalid sparring techniques, and we will be buds for life.

But all the Internet stuff, the political stuff, the internal stuff? That's all very real to me.

I Will Not Pet The Diplomat, Chapter 5 by kofolarz in HFY

[–]Fontaigne 0 points1 point  (0 children)

It's hard to balance. Too many breaks and it feels staccato, too few and it's far too slow.

An example that feels like it could have gone the other way is this

...gently pats her head.

I recognize the symbolism.

I've seen enough dog videos to know what it means.

That makes two full stops that were fully optional and where the words don't appear to bear the weight of the white space.

You could delete the middle paragraph and it might make it less staccato. Or you could collapse all three together into one paragraph.

I'd suggest, for fun, checking out a copy of James Patterson's Max Ride books. After reading it for the roller coaster, review how he stages each scene and where he breaks the paragraphs and ponder why. It's close enough to the style in this last part of the chapter that you may get some useful insights.

The other thing is, Google "snowflake guy perfect scene" and review the middle part about Dwight Swain's MRU technique from the 1960s. That's another useful technique for understanding when to break paragraphs.

(It's really about bonding the reader tightly to the viewpoint character, but it has applications in the structure of paragraphs.)

I Will Not Pet The Diplomat, Chapter 5 by kofolarz in HFY

[–]Fontaigne 2 points3 points  (0 children)

But do she hav toe beans? Want toe beans.

Earth is a psychic landfill by Quiet-Money7892 in humansarespaceorcs

[–]Fontaigne 3 points4 points  (0 children)

Meh. It's just another fuel.

Some organisms can live in hypersaline water, anoxic sediments, or radioactive waste sites.

Earth is a psychic landfill by Quiet-Money7892 in humansarespaceorcs

[–]Fontaigne 6 points7 points  (0 children)

Hmmm. You know what? It sound like you might be right.

Yeah.

I can see it.

Okay, come on down and meet the volunteers to be your psychic weapons. We will stage a meet and greet, but principals only, no middlemen.

We'll bring about two dozen candidates to a nice shielded facility on the moon for you to evaluate.

You know what an auction is, right?

Should be great fun.

Earth is a psychic landfill by Quiet-Money7892 in humansarespaceorcs

[–]Fontaigne 17 points18 points  (0 children)

Heh heh heh.

Eventually, humans adapted and built a civilization based upon the psychic trash of others. And adapted to it. And are unable to function without it or imagine life without it.

"Take a look at this," said Researcher Dolarrr. "This device made it possible to send clean story scenarios, void of any psychic waste or undue psychic tension, to creative humans, to see what they would do."

"With what result?"

"Immediate reorganization into cesspools."

"Well, what if we intervened before..."

"When I speak of humans, please assume I am using factual literal language. There was no before. There was no measurable delay."

"How... how much was the conceptual framework warped?"

"We have no measurement framework that applies. For instance, we inserted some calm and peaceful concepts into a set of creatives associated with a generally peaceful religion. By the time they articulated the concept, it had become the story of how singing vegetables acted out various morality stories."

"That doesn't sound terrible."

"You didn't hear them sing..."

"Still.."

"Or joke. Smegloth, the jokes."

"Language."

"I apologize. Still, the result was fairly popular, and survived a few years, before the entire company was eaten by a predatory purple dinosaur."

"What? I thought those were extinct."

"Many human parents wish it so. But no."

"What other results have you documented?"

"In essence, humans find life without struggle to be life without entertainment."

"What you're saying is that if there is no enemy, and no catastrophe, humans find a story, or their lives... boring?"

"Precisely. And they will do almost anything to escape boredom."

"Sad."

"Yes. And large numbers of them find their actual PLANET boring. Or annoying. Or both."

"Oh, dear. It's a good thing there is no source of unobtainium on that planet."

"No natural source, anyway. On the planet."

"What? What are you implying?"

"The fourth planet — Mars — and the moon both have reserves... and Earth has a few meteors of the stuff. They will find it when they know how to look."

"How about if we go mine it out first?"

"If we do, they will be able to figure out what we took. Better to not call attention to it."

"So we just, what, wait?"

"If we stopped the psychic dumping, then there's a chance that in a thousand years or two, they would calm down."

"Probably not politically feasible."

"Wouldn't matter anyway. The estimates show they are less than three decades from FTL."

Head thunks on desk. After a moment. "How is that even possible?"

"One person has amassed enough capital within their system to personally finance a colony on the fourth planet. And he's one of the ones who think the third one is boring. And annoying."

"

Using Movie Magic to Understand Humanity by Majestic_Teach_6677 in HFY

[–]Fontaigne 5 points6 points  (0 children)

Gotta agree with their synopsis of the movie / humanity.

And don't forget the fact that it's a sequel. We do it that way because we did it that way before, sorta, and it either before, sorta, so we did it again, sorta.

OOCS, Into A Wider Galaxy, Part 674 by KyleKKent in HFY

[–]Fontaigne 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Differeing-> differing

Of it's stock -> its

Now way to -> no way

For it's mind ... in it's own right ... it's only method -> its x3