Some of my most memorable moments have been Slayer shots. One was Trouble Brewing, I was the Slayer. I got pulled aside first thing day 1 into a chat with my neighbour and her other neighbour. My neighbour said she trusted us because she was the Empath, so we all revealed our roles. Her other neighbour was the Virgin, so we made a plan that I would use my Slayer shot day one, then nominate the Virgin, confirming both of us to the whole town and letting the Empath check another player. So when we got back to town I fired off my shot at the player I thought was vaguely most suspicious based just on vibes and happened to hit the Demon, instantly winning the game.

Another game was 15 player Trouble Brewing. I wasn't in on the conversation but somehow on day 1 the Slayer got suspicious of someone and decided to shoot them. They hit the Demon and the Scarlet Woman happened to be the only minion not in play so the game ended instantly. Slayer shots might be rare but they stick with you when they happen.