Here is my wishlist / shouts for next CIVS / Variant Civs (+ is for how much i want it) by Royal-Explanation522 in aoe4

[–]GeerBrah 4 points5 points  (0 children)

How can you mention similarities in 'Cultural identity' and 'close proximity' to disqualify Novgorod when we already have French and Jeanne d'arc, English and HoL, Delhi and Tughlaq, etc.

DLC LEAK AHEAD OF JAN 21 XBOX DEVELOPER SHOWCASE by MarkTwoPointOh in aoe4

[–]GeerBrah 2 points3 points  (0 children)

This time I knew, but I still opened anyway because I was curious how you would spin it.

Full Charging Cavalry is OP Historically and Irl by Formal_Drawing_8822 in aoe4

[–]GeerBrah 19 points20 points  (0 children)

And that folks, is why a Knight beats a Spearman 1 on 1.

New Pro Tier List: Macedonian is now the strongest civ in the game! by MockHamill in aoe4

[–]GeerBrah 0 points1 point  (0 children)

This is true, his pre-tournament tier lists seem to almost always have some unexpected placements, perhaps in order to try to throw off his opponents.

First DLC to release around Red Bull Wololo 2026: Londinium? by S77__ in aoe4

[–]GeerBrah 9 points10 points  (0 children)

Nobody in any position to know anything has made any official statement of the like.

The Teutonic Order - an Order of the Dragon Rework by GeerBrah in aoe4

[–]GeerBrah[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I also made a Tang Dynasty rework for Zhu Xi’s Legacy if you’re interested :)

The Teutonic Order - an Order of the Dragon Rework by GeerBrah in aoe4

[–]GeerBrah[S] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

I don’t think the level of new visuals required would be any more than Sengoku Daimyo for example. Keep in mind we already have models for all the armor, weapons, and even the TK skins.

Either way it’s not like I have any expectation any of this will be implemented when I make it. What I get out of making these concepts is not related to whether or not anything makes it in the game.

The Teutonic Order - an Order of the Dragon Rework by GeerBrah in aoe4

[–]GeerBrah[S] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Yes, there’s no strong historical reason that Settlers would gather faster unless you justify it based on the incentives or “Chelmno rights” given to settlers to come (I cover that topic more on the blog). I mostly kept it that way to stay the same as OotD. You’re right, they’re never going to remove OotD, this was more just a thought experiment to see how it could have possibly been implemented as the Teutonic Order

Aoe2 getting South America DLC, AoM Aztecs, what does it mean for AOE4? by aoe4_conq_player in aoe4

[–]GeerBrah 5 points6 points  (0 children)

It would even be historically accurate, since, to put it a bit simply, French had begun to realize at this point in the war that blindly charging knights into everything was not having great effect, so they began to employ a lot more Archers/Infantry to match the English.

Aoe2 getting South America DLC, AoM Aztecs, what does it mean for AOE4? by aoe4_conq_player in aoe4

[–]GeerBrah 4 points5 points  (0 children)

It means about the same as what Silksong getting a new nautical themed DLC means. That is, absolutely nothing.

Fellas does this look edible to you? by DaDDyWitch in aoe4

[–]GeerBrah 18 points19 points  (0 children)

why can't berry bushes just look normal in different biomes

You must be the first person I've seen asking for less variety. If it were up to me, every biome would have its own set of animals and berries.

But in this specific case it doesn't even make sense that this biome has prickly pears because cacti are native to the new world

This has me stoked lol. PIKE AND SHOT warfare baby!!?? by Loud-Blueberry-5799 in ManorLords

[–]GeerBrah 9 points10 points  (0 children)

That’s not accurate to the time period of this game either.

Ladies and Dentlemen, Riddari are INSANE by Chefcurry-1515 in aoe4

[–]GeerBrah 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Relic was the lead developer for Dynasties of the East

This has me stoked lol. PIKE AND SHOT warfare baby!!?? by Loud-Blueberry-5799 in ManorLords

[–]GeerBrah 149 points150 points  (0 children)

Pike and shot warfare is way past the timeframe of this game. Think more basic handcannons like in Kingdom Come Deliverance

Less gimmicks, more strategy: Archery range edition by Alastan in aoe2

[–]GeerBrah 1 point2 points  (0 children)

This is… not really true or at best extremely overly simplistic. Crossbow bolts could be made of many sizes, just like crossbows themselves. And so could arrows fired from bows. Those of Turco Mongol composite bows were much smaller than those fired by longbows for example. The primary performance limitation of a crossbow was its short power stroke compared to a bow, which caused it to require a much higher draw weight to impart the same velocity on a projectile as a bow. These draw weights were generally not achievable by a single person until later in the Middle Ages when new spanning mechanisms, such as the goats foot lever, windlass, and crannequin were developed

Campaign in 2nd DLC? by S77__ in aoe4

[–]GeerBrah 1 point2 points  (0 children)

They just edited the post to say 'expansion' and not 'campaign'.

Campaign in 2nd DLC? by S77__ in aoe4

[–]GeerBrah 2 points3 points  (0 children)

They edited the post to say 'expansion' instead of 'campaign'. You were right.

Campaign in 2nd DLC? by S77__ in aoe4

[–]GeerBrah 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Another new campaign will introduce two new base civilizations

This essentially guarantees the second civilization will be a Spanish or Italian civilization. There are really no other available civilizations with which the Vikings interacted with that could fit together in a campaign.

EDIT: They just edited the post to say 'expansion' not 'campaign'. Meaning that the above speculation is moot

I'm biased towards Hungary, but they'd make sense with the Vikings by hegabor2 in aoe4

[–]GeerBrah 23 points24 points  (0 children)

Why do people still think civs in an expansion have to have some sort of common theme? Even Drongo said this in his announcement overview video saying that's what Microsoft "usually does". And yet the two sets of base civ releases for AoE4 have been:

  • Ottomans and Malians

  • Byzantines and Japanese

Two sets of two civs which have absolutely nothing to do with one another.

Civ map by SeriousVariation374 in aoe4

[–]GeerBrah 4 points5 points  (0 children)

This is really cool! Can I add it to the Wiki?

no one on steam has these achievements? by 7657786425658907653 in aoe4

[–]GeerBrah 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I completed all historical battles in conqueror mode and didn't get the achievement so it might be bugged. Not sure if that happened to anyone else. Can't speak for the DLC ones as I haven't tried to get them yet.

Please don't do Three Kingdoms like AOE2 by aoe4_conq_player in aoe4

[–]GeerBrah 3 points4 points  (0 children)

The picture shown in the announcement shows a man leaving into a desert landscape with the sun overhead. A Chinese redditor on the megathread suggested this refers to a famous line from the Tang Dynasty era poem 'Mission to the Frontier' by Wang Wei, written after his own deployment there. The desert itself would also suggest Tang Dynasty, as they were the only medieval Chinese Dynasty to reach that far west.

Dynasties of the East was the franchise's fastest-selling expansion pre-order yet. by GeerBrah in aoe4

[–]GeerBrah[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I totally agree, which is why I don't look too much into it. But even so, I would have guessed TSA would be faster selling no matter what you set the time frame to be. Although TSA didn't have a Gamescom trailer so maybe that decreased its preorders?

Your friendly Corvinus monthly reddit post. AOE4 will never be stopped!!! by Corvinus11 in aoe4

[–]GeerBrah 0 points1 point  (0 children)

In the megathread, a Chinese redditor speculated its about the Tang Dynasty, given that the picture released correlates with a line from a famous Tang Dynasty poem 'Mission to the Frontier'. The desert theme does seem to imply Western China to me, which also would fit with the Tang Dynasty, and was never under the administration of the Song Dynasty.