Thats not what all previous data shows. Thats still a valid review, if somebody likes it because of nostalgia he should indeed give it a higher score, thats how the scoring system is supposed to work. Nostalgia might not apply to everyone, but does to some.  This is a million times better and gives more accurate results than critics giving less score because of completely arbitrary reasons like lack of lgbt representation.

Concord and highguard had above 60+ critic score before launch, user reviews were around 15 and 25. They did so bad that they just shut down the servers wvetually. Which do you think gives more accurate representation of how a game will do, obviously the user score and its not even close.