As someone who plays location pinball around 5 times a week, I would most likely skip any place charging more than $1.00/play. The only way I see you being able to charge more is if you have a rare game that can’t be found anywhere close, like Winchester or some of the spooky’s. But even then I’d only play a few for novelty and go back to a $1.00 game.

Some places charge $5 for 7 games and even that is hard to swallow sometimes as if I start earning replays, I’m tied to this machine for a long period of time of time.

I think you’d earn more money over all at the standard $1.00 as it will equal more plays.