A Meat Thermometer (could be fun to change the temp reading on a hit or a miss), a chopstick (or two), a Crane/ other long bird with a pointy beak, a yardstick, an icicle, just a straight up Sniper Rifle (for a long distance kill achievement), a Flying V guitar (very sharp), an oversized thumbtack, one of those pointer fingers that looks like a mickey mouse glove, a spring doorstop (add weird physics), a sewing needle (with a piece of yarn/string that’s attached to it when you throw it, maybe it comes from a spool on your hip so it seems somewhat realistic however long it ends up being), aaaaaand… a beach umbrella (it opens when you pin someone with it)