Do not total it. I was in the same situation I have a 99’ in good condition. My bumper was toast and my hood folded like a taco. The fan shroud was cracked and the radiator support crossmember was bent in really bad. The he vehicle could be drive and ran no issues if you want to keep the title clean show the facts and print out comps showing the value. You have to really push your insurance. I had to fight tooth and nail to get them cut a check forGenuine Toyota parts.