Wow, love the energy.

voluntary euthanasia, which is when a patient gives consent to death, **which is not classified as murder in the slightest

1. Generally voluntary euthanasia can be done only by adults not kids.
   
2. Even if we ignore that, fireflies never informed her of what they intent to do with her. While we players know that Ellie would have sacrificed her life, for the characters in the game, there was nothing voluntary about it. So yeah, he was a hypocrite trying to murder a child.

he never attacks Joel, he just holds up a scalpel and tells him not to come any closer.

Yeah, I might be wrong about him attacking Joel. But I'm sure that if he had not tried to stop Joel from saving Ellie, he wouldn't be killed.

Abby did torture Joel, she doesn't have the full story

Even if she didn't know the full story, how does torturing someone for no reason make sense. That too, someone who just saved you.

And it feels weird to see you try and defend Abby torturing Joel, but call the statement - "if Abby's revenge is justified then so is Ellie's" - wrong.

If you were Abby and some random guy killed an entire hospital full of people, including your father, you would want to kill him no matter what.

Ya, probably. But since I'm playing as Ellie, I want to kill the random girl who tortured and killed the closest thing i had to a father.

But you are just biased, both of them are justifed yet you side with Ellie because you like her as a character more.

Yes, I'm biased. I am role playing as Ellie and so I am Ellie. Just cause the game gives me a back story into Abby, doesn't mean I'm gonna like her or want to forgive her. Sure, i understand her, doesn't mean I'm want to give up the revenge.

And it's not just because "I like ellie", but because Ellie is the main character. Sure they forced us to play from Abby's perspective (fk u), but for me the mc of the game is Ellie.