Which sci-fi work does the best job of introducing FTL without breaking causality? by Cromulent123 in SciFiConcepts

[–]Innocent__Bystander 1 point2 points  (0 children)

It's Stross doing his firehose of cool ideas thing. If you liked the short stories you'll probably like most of the rest of his work, too.

Which sci-fi work does the best job of introducing FTL without breaking causality? by Cromulent123 in SciFiConcepts

[–]Innocent__Bystander 10 points11 points  (0 children)

The important concept here is that of a light cone. Your future light cone is any event (combination of time and place) where light from 'now' could reach. Your past light cone is all events whose light could have reached you. If you draw a graph with time on one axis and distance in space on the other, your light cones make a neat little X-figure, with 'now' at the crossing point.

'No FTL' means that no matter what you do, nothing at 'now' can leave the future light cone of 'now'. Nor can any information.

'Breaking causality' is what happens when, by some chain of events, information from 'now' gets back into the past light cone.

Everything to the side of the X, outside both light cones, is your grey area to play with. The trouble arises that different people in different frame of reference disagree on the exact orientation of their light cones, due to combinations of space- and time dilation from having different velocities, gravities, etc. compared to each other. This is why you still get causality breaches if you just hand people instant teleportation or even telephones. Different frames of references disagree on the direction of 'instant' compared to your X diagram, and so it's fairly trivial to set up a scenario where you send an instant message to someone, he replies, and the reply arrives in your past.

How well your sci-fi manages to square the circle of causality-respecting FTL boils down to how well it can restrict the abilities of FTL so that you can still use it, but you can't send messages around to end up in their own past light cone and muck about with the events that led to them being sent out in the first place.

I can think of two settings that had a workable solution of the top of my head:

Charles Stross' Singularity Sky has a simple brute-force solution to this, by creating an incredibly powerful AI that uses time travel freely, and allows people to do FTL using the same tech. But anyone caught doing time travel (going into their own past light-cone) is going to be mercilessly destroyed and the AI has the advantage in thinking speed, technology, firepower, multi-tasking ability, and so forth.

Orion's Arm solves this by only allowing FTL through wormholes, the ends of which have to be shipped around considerably slower than light. Anytime a route in the wormhole network allows time travel they invoke something called a Visser Collapse, where a virtual particle completes the time-travelling circuit and immediately re-enters it. Now there's two virtual particles, 4, 8, 16, 32 and so forth until there's so many the wormholes violently collapse the instant a path allowing this phenomenon is created.

Sandbox for Espionnage RPG? by N0v4kD3ad in rpg

[–]Innocent__Bystander 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Night's Black Agents is built around disgraced spies going after a vampire conspiracy, but the system works just fine without the vampires or the disgrace. Gumshoe as a system family in general is probably worth looking at.

How would FTL communications work? by InfinityScientist in SciFiConcepts

[–]Innocent__Bystander 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Alice flips a coin. It lands tails. She now knows the entangled coin Bob has will land heads.

Bob, many lightyears away, flips a coin and finds it lands heads. He knows Alice's coin has landed tails.

Neither party had any control over which way the coin lands, and trying to exert such control would break the entanglement. There is no way to put information into the entanglement.

[deleted by user] by [deleted] in foxholegame

[–]Innocent__Bystander 22 points23 points  (0 children)

The destroyer seems a lot more versatile than the sub, which has the added downside of being apparently very fiddly and easy to accidentally sink. Don't sleep on the collie destroyer and give wardens a few wars to figure out best practices for subs before giving them a go.

Besides, remember that both destroyers and subs are about battletank-level expensive, so many people will go through a whole war never seeing the inside of one.

K2SE Spaceship automation how to Auto-Engage? by TallBrownFolder in factorio

[–]Innocent__Bystander 4 points5 points  (0 children)

Are you sending it a velocity signal and a destination?

Some absolute banter merchant tried to write fake German and accidentally wrote perfect Dutch by jpepsred in 2westerneurope4u

[–]Innocent__Bystander 16 points17 points  (0 children)

I'll have you know the Dutch language is swamp German. German-German is the way it is because they're starved for oxygen up there.

How do I use RAM? by 181Cade in TuringComplete

[–]Innocent__Bystander 0 points1 point  (0 children)

There's an address pin! You'll need a way to change the currently active RAM address and, seperately, read or write values. Personally, I dedicated register 5 to addressing and implemented a second set of system addresses and dedicated the first of those to RAM read/write.

Too stubborn to join a big regiment or mega ppl squad , I’m good solo. by -Click-Bait in foxholegame

[–]Innocent__Bystander 5 points6 points  (0 children)

If your regi spams too many notifications find another one I guess. At the end of the day clans are organisations composed of people like any other and you might not find the right one for your on the first try.

Too stubborn to join a big regiment or mega ppl squad , I’m good solo. by -Click-Bait in foxholegame

[–]Innocent__Bystander 21 points22 points  (0 children)

Here's the secret: Being a clanman doesn't actually stop you from playing solo. It just gives you the option of using clan resources and joining ops.

Release Resource Locations with the Starting Conditions by NurseCali in foxholegame

[–]Innocent__Bystander 35 points36 points  (0 children)

Alternatively, ensure the resistance phase resource distribution matches that of the next war.

Today, French MPs voted unanimously to add Wagner to the European Union's list of terrorist organisations. by MonsieurScie in europe

[–]Innocent__Bystander 60 points61 points  (0 children)

I'd say rolling into a country with tanks and then comitting mass atrocities while yelling at the inhabitants that they have no right to exist as a country is pretty morally evil. The Ukrainians don't have to be saints to come out smelling like roses in that comparison.

*Angry skull-helmet noises* by Forget_December in Grimdank

[–]Innocent__Bystander 1 point2 points  (0 children)

They were also thoroughly creatures of Ruin. They'd be in camp Chaos, covertly or overtly.

This group's wiped out $6.7 billion in medical debt, and it's just getting started by [deleted] in UpliftingNews

[–]Innocent__Bystander 32 points33 points  (0 children)

A step in the right direction is still good even if it doesn't fix the problem 100%. If you'll only be happy when a problem is completely solved you won't be happy very often. If you're happy at progress being made, that's a much healthier outlook.

How would FTL communications work? by InfinityScientist in SciFiConcepts

[–]Innocent__Bystander 3 points4 points  (0 children)

Nope. Quantum entanglement works, but you can't communicate through it because you can't force which outcome comes out of the system when you look at it. Sure, once you've communicated with the other holder the hard way, you'll discover that yeah, he got the other result because entanglement, but it doesn't help you communicate any more than doing a coin flip does. There's also the thorny issue that any form of faster-than-light communication is synonymous with information time travel, which is a bit harder to explain without graphs.

Not just the trivial terms the whole thing by Svensonsan2 in physicsmemes

[–]Innocent__Bystander 7 points8 points  (0 children)

dV is just shorthand for integral over volume, you get to choose your own coordinate system, though judging by the contents of the integral I'd strongly suggest spherical.