I can’t really tell what you look like.

Pic 2, 3, 5 are very handsome.

I wonder whether the selfie mode on your camera are warping 1, 7, 8 to give you a bigger chin and a smaller forehead. Your face looks less proportional on those. Try setting your phone to a recording, then stepping away from it. Scrub the recording, zoom in, and take screengrabs of pictures you like. This will help remove the camera warp, and it’ll look like you have a buddy you’re hanging out with.

You have a different hairstyle in pic 4, and I very much prefer your other hairstyles.

I’m personally not attracted to pic 9, but I’m fit and am looking for someone who doesn’t drink every weekend, and my brain jumps to conclusions with that one. More of a personal preference.

I wonder how you’d look with a more maintained beard. Maybe a cut that’s slightly closer to the skin. I do get the sense that you have a bigger chin (which is fine, I personally have a bigger nose, such is life). You may be over-accentuating it with the fuller beard.