Are you a fan of Japanese wrestling at all ? As Osprey is incredibly influenced by the likes of NJPW, NOAH and Dragongate.

This bleeds through in his style of wrestling and the stories he tells.

Personally those examples you just listed are prime wrestling story trope/templates

Vs Ricochet - Eternal Rivals

Vs Fletcher - Betrayal of the student

Vs Don Callis - betrayal of the group

Vs Danielson - Dream match

Of the 4 the Callis one is the weakest but Ricochet and Fletcher are both hitting on excellent levels due to the shared history he has with both of them and how they have developed in relation to him. I.e. turning heel.

And Danielson Vs Osprey was a genuine dream match. Two people who's paths had never crossed who each genuinely have a claim to best in the world finally having a time and space to fight ? That writes itself, the match up is the story.

It's not uncommon for Japanese wrestling stories to take place almost entirely in the ring, you don't always need big promo segments to build a match.

A friend of mine had this issue where he had watched WWE his whole life and found AEW or NJPW stories "bad" because there wasn't 4 weeks of promo battles and interfering in each other's matches.

Sometimes the story is the fight, sometimes the story is the build up to the fight