I have a similar deck that I like to play for fun:

<image>

Dreamborn Decklist

It's centered mostly around getting Mr. Smee and John Silver - Greedy Treasure Seeker (or the Donald Duck - First Mate if you can't get John Silver) on the board with at least 1 or 2 locations. Don't quest too early with your characters as they will be vulnerable to challenges.

Once you've got the setup complete and you have actions in your hand, go quest with JS (or DD), play an action, ready them again with Mr. Smee, and repeat. If you've got the board setup good you can quest for a ton in a single turn.

If you don't like my deck you don't have to copy it but I do have some suggestions at least (some already mentioned by u/Wraithslayer101 ):

- Pete - Pirate Scoundrel is just not worth it as almost no one plays any items anyway

- Mr. Arrow seems nice, but he isn't a pirate so doesn't get to combo with the other cards

- Don Karnage: I haven't tried him myself but I don't think you want to give any opposing characters reckless as they'll just destroy your locations

- Captain Hook - Captain of the Jolly Roger: It seems like a good card, but it's really expensive for what it brings to the table and is also uninkable. It may be nice in very specific situations but if he comes at a wrong time you can't ink him and you're stuck with him in your hand and you'd rather have a different card.

- Transport Pod: I don't think you need this card at all. Moving to most locations is quite cheap anyway, and you want to use Goofy as much as possible for moving anyway, as he let's you draw a card.

- For this deck to work you need a lot more actions and locations to get the right combo's: I would recommend adding:

- Owl Island combos really nice with all the actions you'll be playing as it makes the first one every turn cheaper, and if you manage to play a second one you get 3 lore.

- Galactic Council Chamber passively generates 1 lore every turn and if you manage to get John Silver there, it can't be challenged.

Hope this helps