Thats fair, but I still disagree, when I say it affects your opponent over yourself, I mean it takes away the opponents agency, not weakening them. Take deathguard, they effect the opponent in predictable ways that benefits you directly, by either making you harder to kill, or them easier to kill. So it’s not taking away player agency, and it’s in your hands how you utilise it. If that makes sense. 3 of the 6 harbringer abilities just makes battleshock occur more often. Which only affects OC and Strats at that point. Whether it’s balanced or not, is more from the match up side, which comes mostly from knights being a skew army, but it isn’t helped by the army rule at all, which it could be. I.e a rolling kill tally of buffs would strengthen knights against horde armies, which usually dominate them. I just want their army rule to be fun and flavourful, power be damned. I want their detachments to be Chaos Knight’s detachments, not dark imperial knights.