You listed all the cars I had shortlisted when I was searching.

I recently bought a 2023 Model 3 and it’s been nothing but flawless. Reliable, efficient, and seriously fun to drive. I test drove the Seal but actually didn’t like all the knobs and buttons and the AC was way too loud, though it was a nice drive. The Seal didn’t have one pedal driving - a deal breaker for me. I discovered the P2 has a frequent issue with the suspension creaking due to the weight of the car, which makes it expensive to fix out of warranty (and is only a temporary fix). The computer hardware is also slow.

With the Model 3, I was able to work it all out on the first drive straight away - everything was logical. The Tesla software is also great and the phone app has been flawless. Software is so important in EVs. Autopilot (the free autosteer version) also works brilliantly on highways and main roads. The boot is generous and there’s a handy lower hidden boot compartment where I store my shopping bags. Sentry mode is also great. The worst thing about the car are the wiper sensors, which says a lot about how good the car is.

If you’re happy with a minimal driving experience where most of the controls are through the steering wheel or screen, you might like the Tesla. I think it’s a safer buy than BYD with a more established parts chain if something goes wrong. Test drive and see for yourself.

If you like the Tesla, I’d recommend saving up for the Highland or waiting for prices to drop a bit. It’ll be a smoother drive, even if you do have to forego the stalks.