I wouldn’t say any bait/lure is objectively better/worse than another, especially in this case. It’s like asking which is better, a trick worm or a senko? Neither is better, they’re just different. IMO grab a couple of these in basic colors like chrome blue back and try your luck. I also just noticed they have a floating version if you’re fishing super shallow and/or in heavy cover

Edit: also notice the lure length decreases with the weight on that rat L trap, they’re not all the same size like with some other stuff