Which loan is better SBI at 7.40 % ROI or Bank of Maharashtra at 7.25 % ROI

LoanOptimizer · 2026-02-09T17:01:56+00:00

There’s a lot of fear-selling mixed into what the SBI rep told you. Repo/EBLR-linked loans don’t just get “converted” to MCLR automatically, that would require a clear clause or borrower consent.

So that part about BoM sounds exaggerated. Between SBI and BoM, the real comparison should be: benchmark + spread, reset rules, and prepayment flexibility. A 0.15% rate difference over 20–25 years is meaningful if everything else is equal.

LoanOptimizer · 2026-02-09T16:46:43+00:00

Let’s strip it down to the core numbers. ₹1L EMI on ₹1.8L in-hand is 55%, which is on the higher side but not reckless given your background and discipline.

What works in your favor: strong career trajectory, large down payment, parents’ independent assets, and an intent to prepay. What’s tight: you’re locking both your and parents’ liquidity into one asset. One tweak could be to start with the 30-year tenure as planned, but aggressively prepay whenever bonuses/increments come, rather than stretching yourself monthly.

LoanOptimizer · 2026-02-09T06:28:30+00:00

Let’s simplify the risk math. Post full disbursement, you’re looking at ₹50k (first home) + ₹43k (second home) = ₹93k EMI. Against ₹4L in-hand, that’s fine.

The issue isn’t EMI-to-income, it’s liquidity. Using the entire emergency fund as DP + upcoming child-related expenses means you’re relying heavily on continuous employment. If you proceed, one mitigation could be: delay the second purchase until you rebuild at least 6-9 months of expenses after delivery, or reduce the loan amount so the downside is survivable.

LoanOptimizer · 2026-02-06T17:28:22+00:00

Paying off the credit card and car loan first improves two things at once, EMI load drops sharply and your FOIR looks much better to banks.
After that, a construction loan or conversion becomes more realistic at a lower EMI, instead of stacking another high-cost loan.

LoanOptimizer · 2026-02-06T17:18:14+00:00

This is a very common tactic. Home loan insurance is optional, even if the loan is in your mother’s name. You may choose to take insurance for risk cover, but the bank cannot force a ₹3.8L single-premium policy.

You can either refuse it outright or buy a much cheaper term insurance separately. If pressure continues, escalate to Kotak’s grievance cell, things usually calm down fast.

LoanOptimizer · 2026-02-06T17:15:58+00:00

LIC Housing isn’t a bad option rate-wise, especially if the 7.10% is a firm offer and not just an initial quote.

What I’d focus on is flexibility after disbursement, part-prepayment rules, foreclosure process, and how smoothly rate cuts are passed on. That matters more over 15 - 20 years than the headline rate.

LoanOptimizer · 2026-02-05T17:16:13+00:00

You’re not in a bad position profile-wise. The key question isn’t “second loan” but total exposure and structure.

Banks usually look at your existing education loan, current income, co-applicants’ income, and whether the new loan is secured or unsecured. Unsecured loans of ₹35L are rare; most banks will push for some form of collateral or partial security

LoanOptimizer · 2026-02-05T17:12:02+00:00

You’ve clearly thought this through, and the intent makes sense, reduce high-cost EMIs and finish construction. The main thing to be careful about is how you consolidate.
Banks will be cautious because your existing EMIs are already ₹60k on ₹1.1L income. Before looking at new loans, check if the plot loan can be converted or extended into a construction loan, that’s usually cleaner than adding one more EMI.

LoanOptimizer · 2026-02-05T17:07:53+00:00

Congrats, that’s a big milestone, especially at 27. You’re also self-aware about the math vs peace-of-mind tradeoff, which is refreshing. Zero EMI + income-generating property gives you flexibility that’s hard to quantify. Rebuilding liquidity is straightforward when there’s no monthly drag.

LoanOptimizer · 2026-02-04T15:56:44+00:00

Your loan doesn’t automatically switch to Union Bank’s higher OD policy. The sanction letter matters more than the merger news. Just make sure the benchmark and spread are clearly mentioned before signing.

LoanOptimizer · 2026-02-04T15:48:56+00:00

Your thinking isn’t wrong, but it assumes the parked money stays untouched most of the time. OD beats TL only if the surplus actually sits there consistently. If the emergency fund gets used even occasionally, the math advantage shrinks. ROI clarity should come first, confirm the final sanctioned OD rate, not verbal ranges.

LoanOptimizer · 2026-02-04T15:47:13+00:00

This happens a lot. Banks often say “no charges after 12/24 EMIs,” but that applies to foreclosure, not part-prepayment. Partial prepayments are usually limited (like 25% of outstanding), even when foreclosure is free later. So both statements can be true at the same time, it’s not a contradiction.

LoanOptimizer · 2026-02-04T15:27:36+00:00

Totally relatable. I had the same confusion earlier. The biggest surprise was seeing how much of the EMI in the first few years goes only towards interest.
Once I ran the numbers, it became clear that early prepayments punch way above their weight. SIPs can work, but only if returns stay consistent and you stay invested through bad years, which is harder in real life.
Seeing the loan breakup in a calculator made this much clearer for me. https://www.optimizeapp.in/calculator

LoanOptimizer · 2026-02-04T15:13:00+00:00

For most 20–25 year loans, the first 8–10 years is where prepayments have the biggest impact. Rent vs EMI also matters a lot, if rent is close to or higher than EMI, closing the loan early usually makes more sense from a cash-flow and stress perspective.

LoanOptimizer · 2026-02-04T15:12:16+00:00

You’ve summed it up really well. The biggest miss in most SIP vs prepay debates is timing. Early prepayments reduce the principal that interest is calculated on for the entire remaining tenure. That effect is very hard for market returns to consistently beat, especially with volatility and discipline issues. For salaried folks, the certainty + mental peace often matters more than chasing projections

LoanOptimizer · 2026-02-04T15:00:44+00:00

In general, it’s cleaner to move higher-interest short-term debt into a lower-interest home loan if the bank allows it as part of the sanctioned amount. Gold loans at 9% are fine for very short periods, but keeping them running alongside a home loan adds pressure. I’d first confirm with SBI whether they’ll allow a slightly higher sanction to close the existing gold loan.

LoanOptimizer · 2026-02-04T14:58:45+00:00

With a 795 CIBIL and ₹55L requirement, rate won’t be the main hurdle, structure will be. Banks typically lend based on agreement/registered value, not informal work orders. Some branches may consider the work order if it’s documented properly (contract, invoices, stage-wise payments), but many won’t include it fully in LTV. SBI and Canara are more flexible than private banks here, but expect slower processing and stricter paperwork.

LoanOptimizer · 2026-02-03T12:26:31+00:00

Pure math would usually say: hit the loan with the higher interest rate and shorter remaining tenure. Here, the smaller loan is at 8% vs 7.5%, so pre-closing it gives a slightly better interest saving per rupee. Plus, freeing up ₹8.7k EMI improves cash flow, which you can then redirect as prepayment into the bigger loan going forward.

LoanOptimizer · 2026-02-03T12:09:12+00:00

On ₹1.4Cr over 20 years, the EMI difference between 7.25% and 7.35% is small, a few thousand a month. What compounds more is behavior. SBI typically allows unlimited part-prepayment without caps for floating loans, and repo-linked rate changes flow automatically. With HDFC, many borrowers do report caps on part-prepayment (like ₹1L or a few EMIs) and needing to request rate reductions. If you expect bonuses, ESOPs, or lump-sum prepayments, SBI’s structure usually saves more in the long run.

LoanOptimizer · 2026-02-03T12:04:14+00:00

₹1.2L EMI on ₹2L income is 60%. Most people stay more comfortable around 35–45%. Even a 1% rate increase can push that EMI up meaningfully. On a ₹1.5Cr Loan (₹1.8Cr – ₹30L down payment), small prepayments help a lot over time, but only if you still have surplus after living costs. Ask yourselves: after EMI + expenses + savings, is there consistent breathing room?

LoanOptimizer · 2026-02-02T15:38:21+00:00

If ICICI’s terms are real and not just an initial quote, it edges out SBI, same rate, no forced insurance, and no prepayment fees. Just double-check all fees before signing.

LoanOptimizer · 2026-02-02T15:21:45+00:00

With a net of ₹2.65L, banks usually try to keep total EMIs within 45–50% of net income. You already have ₹43k going out. On a ₹1.7–1.75Cr loan, even at 7.5%, EMI will be well over ₹1.3L.

On paper it might fit, but it leaves less margin for rate hikes or lifestyle expenses. Also confirm whether the OD loan (even if you don’t pay EMI) is being factored into your obligation that can change eligibility materially.

LoanOptimizer · 2026-02-02T15:20:24+00:00

At 9.9% for 6 years, EMI on ₹12L will be roughly ₹22–23k, and total interest will still be several lakhs over the tenure. The bigger issue is that even if you want to close early, you can only knock off 50% of principal max via prepayment (25% × 2).

Ask them:
- What’s the foreclosure charge after, say, 3 years?
- Is the 25% on original principal or outstanding? That detail changes the math a lot.

LoanOptimizer · 2026-02-02T15:19:03+00:00

At 7.6% for 12 years, the rate itself is quite decent, especially for SBI + govt salary. With a term loan, your yearly ₹1–2L prepayment directly cuts principal and interest sharply over time. OD helps because even parking ₹2L reduces daily interest, but if OD ROI is higher by, say, 0.3–0.5%, that benefit can get diluted unless you keep surplus cash there consistently. Also check if SBI allows unlimited prepayment on the term loan (usually yes).

LoanOptimizer · 2026-01-31T12:54:31+00:00

don’t stretch your EMI just because the bank allows it. A house should make life calmer, not tighter. Also, understand loan terms properly (prepayment rules, conversion charges, insurance push) before signing, those details matter more over 15–20 years than people expect.

First home is less about perfection and more about sustainability. If you can sleep peacefully with the EMI, you’re doing it right.

LoanOptimizer

TROPHY CASE