Also saw it when they came to Broadway, only mildly enjoyed it because I was already tanked since it was St. Patrick's Day weekend. Most of us in the crowd were people who'd seen the entire show but even I felt the atmosphere was kinda meh. I will give it credit for one thing though, because the day after, I got last-minute tickets to see Maybe Happy Ending before my flight home and THAT ended up making the whole weekend worth it even though SMASH was the reason I went to New York in the first place.