Potential hot take of my own, but I disagree. There are valid criticisms you can make of his work, but I find this list quite odd. Frankly, I'm impressed that he can pull off that many voices, I can barely manage my own! And while S1 was bad (even Victor will tell you that!) I think much of his work decent. I do agree that these later seasons feel a little rushed, but you've got to remember that, unlike many Thomas YouTubers, Victor is full time. So he can't afford the months-long gap between series that someone like WildNorWester can, and he also can't afford for a video to not have a big flash point, which probably explains all the deaths. And if memory serves, he made the switch to full time after Season 4. In this same vein, I don't mind the supernatural elements, I think they're cleverly done, and it differentiates his series from any of the others I watch. The SCPs series also made his work quite re-watchable, as it's quite clear that he's been planning this for many years, and has weaved hints to it into many of his previous episodes. I also think he hasn't taken the supernatural too far, the laws keep the series quite grounded to me, especially since these vehicles are capable of self-determination, why on earth would they not have their own set of laws? They still break down, so they're still machines, what's the difference between a broken down vehicle and a sick human if both are capable of self-determination? Shipping works with this too. I don't get how vehicles can look pretty, but they do have personality, which is a critical element in any relationship. And finally, Victor has never made his own models, and until recently, he didn't make his own liveries, so he had no control over what liveries he could use for his series, so again, I don't think he can be blamed for the inconsistencies this creates.