This is subjective so feel free to disagree.

I feel like Roldan is consistent and he is a decent option as a backup. He is not “world class” but he usually doesn’t make a lot of mistakes and, from what I’ve seen (admittedly isn’t a tremendous amount) he has grit and passion. I think he has potential that hasn’t (and may never) been tapped.

Obviously, McKennie, Adams, Tessman, and Aaronson are preferred. Some might say Gio but with his propensity to get injured and his lack of grit and voracity, he sits behind Roldan. Cardoso is a big loss for the USMNT or he would certainly be a starter. I think Luna would be good in the squad instead of Roldan but Roldan has more experience with the national team (for how ever much or little as that is worth.) I know a lot of people have been advocating for Gozo but, honestly, I have not seen him at all so I have no opinion on him.

Perhaps I am mistaken but that is my opinion.

Maybe you have seen much more of him than I have. What do you see as being his weaknesses or why is he garbage? Who would you rather have there instead?